Dawson: James Van Der Beek
Joey: Kaite Holmes
Pacey: Joshua Jackson
Jen: Michelle Williams
Original Airdate: April 28, 1998
(Dawson's room. Dawson is pacing back and forth by his closet while Joey is sitting on Dawson's bed reading a magazine.)
Dawson: Do you realize it's been nearly two weeks since Jen and I broke up and not once has she made an effort to get together? Spend some time, I mean, go to the movies. I...you think that's odd? It seems a little odd to me.
Joey: Dawson, you are aware that she broke up with you, right?
Dawson: Of course I am. It's just there's a certain way to handle these things, you know. I thought Jen would hold us up to it.
(Dawson lays down on his bed next to Joey.)
Joey: Look, Dawson. You don't sound like a guy who's disappointed in Jen's break-up etiquette. You sound like a guy who can't face the reality that it's over. Joey gets up from the bed and stands in front of Dawson. You know, not to sound harsh but you can't live in the past. You have to start preparing for life after Jen.
(Joey leans over and Dawson sits up.)
Dawson: Something tells me Joey has a theory.
Joey: Okay. There are three main ideas to focus on. First-public perception.
Dawson: Such as?
Joey: Well, from now until the end of the semester, you'll be known as the guy Jen dropped. Most girls will view you as tainted goods and of course, there will be the few who'll feel incredibly sorry for you and offer a certain kind of sympathy. My advice-
Dawson: That's easy enough. What's next?
Joey: Other guys.
Dawson: Other guys?
Joey: Look, Dawson, you have to be prepared for the possibility that Jen will begin dating again and seeing her around school with her new boyfriend, watching her from this very window as she pauses coyly at her garden gate, accepts a good night kiss from a guy you feel is physically and intelligently superior to in every way and you can't possibly..
Dawson: Okay, Joey. I...um...get the premise. What's the third thing?
Joey: You and Jen
Dawson: Me and Jen?
Joey: Yeah. The inevitable conversation, which frankly, I'm surprised you haven't had yet. You know, she'll ask if you think the two of you can be friends again, because she'd really like that if you could and you say?
(Joey looks at Dawson who isn't really paying attention to her anymore.)
Joey: Come on, Dawson. You have to have an answer. You say?
Dawson: I don't know. I want to be her friend. But then again, I don't. I mean, how could you simply be friends with someone when every time you look at them, all you think about is how much more you really want them.
(Dawson stands up and looks at Joey. This time it's Joey who's a little distant.)
Joey: Well, you know, I'm no expert at this, Dawson....but I think it can be done.
(The Leery house. Mitch is sitting at the kitchen table reading the newspaper and drinking a cup of coffee. Gail is standing next to the counter drinking her coffee. The phone rings and Mitch picks up the cordless.)
Mitch: Hello?... Yeah, hold on. She's right here. (He puts his hand over the receiver and signals to Gail.) Gail?
(Gail walks over and takes the phone from Mitch.)
Gail: Hello. This is Gail... You know, this is probably not a good time... Yes. Why don't we talk about this in the office?...Yes... Okay... Good-bye. (She hangs up.)
Mitch: Was that Calvin? I wish I had known. I haven't talked to him in a long time.
Gail: No, it wasn't Calvin.
Mitch: No? The voice sounded familiar. Who was it?
Gail: It was work related. It isn't what you think of us.
Mitch: He has the nerve to call here?
Gail: He had a simple question.
Mitch: Oh. Well, you can tell Bob that the next time he calls here, the next time he interrupts my breakfast to call my wife, that the only simple question he'll need an answer for is 'do you have health insurance?'
Gail: It doesn't mean anything. You don't have to be angry with him.
Mitch: That's wonderful. No greater way to start the day than hearing my wife defend an innocent motivation of her former lover. You know what Gail? You're right. I'm angry. It just doesn't happen to be at Bob. (Mitch leaves the room.)
Gail: Mitch? Mitch? Mitchell!
(Cut to Capeside High. Dawson comes down the stairs and walks by the lockers. Jen sees him and stops to talk to him.)
Jen: Hi. How are you doing?
Dawson: Great. Great. You?
Jen: Great. Uh, Dawson. Uh. Look I know...I know that, uh, sometimes after a breakup, well, there's that awkward period where, you know, where two people who used to have so much to say to each other suddenly find their conversations reduced to the merest of small talk.
Dawson: So, what are you saying?
Jen: I'm saying what somebody always says. And what somebody else never wants to hear. But...But you think it's possible in some inconceivable way we could still be friends, Dawson?
(Cut to the Biology class. Dawson and Pacey are seated at a lab table before class begins.)
Pacey: So she asked you to be her friend. What did you say?
Dawson: I didn't say anything, really. I just kind of stared at her then I told her I needed time to think about it.
Pacey: That's okay, Dawson. You still got some work to do here but I think we can salvage this.
Dawson: What are you talking about?
Pacey: Well, uh, just between you and me. There is no way of hope you simply want to be Jen's friend. You're still carrying around this huge torch for her that has no hope of extinguishing itself anytime too soon. Correct?
Pacey: The last person who needs to know about this external flame is Jen. What serves your purpose here is to let her know that you're completely over her, okay? It's yesterday's news, that's the quickest way to the ultimate goal of getting Jen back.
Dawson: How do I do that?
(Mary Beth walks over to them.)
Mary Beth: Hey, Dawson.
Dawson: Hey, Mary Beth.
Mary Beth: So, I hear we're getting out midterms back today.
Dawson: Yeah? Can't wait.
(Mary Beth leaves to sit down.)
Pacey: Now. Upgrading Jen to girlfriend status. It's really a two part attack. The first thing you got to do is let her know that you're completely cool with the idea of being her friend. Okay? The quicker you can fake some sort of indifference, the less special she's going to feel. And the less special she feels, the more she's going to crave that very special feeling that comes from being Dawson Leery's girlfriend. Okay. A feeling that's not included in the friends package.
(The bell rings to begin class.)
Dawson: So, What's the second thing?
Pacey: Slow down, my friend. Let's not get ahead of ourselves.
(Dr. Ram, the biology teacher enters the room.)
Dr. Ram: Okay. The rumor is true. You will be getting your midterm exams back today. Good news is, most of you did very well. Before I hand them back, I'd like to see the following people after class. Those people are...(he flips through the test papers in his hand)...Pacey Witter. Well, I guess that's it.
(Cut to after class. Pacey is still at his lab desk looking over his test while Mr. Ram is standing at the front of the classroom.)
Dr. Ram: Look, Pacey. I know you're a bright kid. You know what I did the first thing after I finished grading your exam?
Pacey: Stopped laughing?
Dr. Ram: I went to the guidance office and looked at your standardized test scores. You have an aptitude for this stuff,
Pacey. So when a student who's really bright makes a 32 on a midterm, you know who's fault that is?
Dr. Ram: Of course not. It's entirely yours. Look, maybe Marine Biology is not your thing. Alright. Fine. I'm not offended but I'm going to make you an offer that I highly recommend you accept. I want you to complete an extra credit project for me. Show me you understand everything we're learning here and I'll pass you. By the skin of your teeth.
Pacey: Yeah? Sure. What do I have to do?
Dr. Ram: Well, first, wait for a student from my sixth period class to arrive.
Pacey: Great. Another rocket scientist I presume?
Dr. Ram: And then I'm going to assign a project that the two of you will work on after school and on free periods.
Joey: Hi, Dr. Ram. (Joey sees Pacey in the room.) Oh. Um, I can come back if you need some time.
Dr. Ram: No, No, you're right on schedule. Joey, I'd like you to meet your new lab partner.
Pacey: Her? Dr. Ram, I'd like to log a formal protest. You never told me I was going to be working with a repressed control freak.
Joey: Yeah, and you never said my grade was dependent on helping some remedial underachiever.
Dr. Ram: Well. Wonderful. I see no introductions are necessary.
(Jen is at her locker when Dawson comes up to her.)
Dawson: Jen? Hi.
Dawson: Um, I'm a little embarrassed. You asked me a very simple question earlier and I really should have given you a very simple answer. Jen, I would love to be your friend.
Dawson: Absolutely. And to ease any of your remaining doubts, I'll prove it to you.
Dawson: Okay. So, let's have a friendly conversation, how was your day?
Jen: Not too bad. Yourself?
Dawson: Excellent. Any exciting plans for the upcoming weekend?
Jen: Look, Dawson. You know your friendship means a lot to me but maybe this isn't such a great idea.
Dawson: Come on. We're friends now, okay? Whatever it is, I think I can take it.
Jen: Okay. Okay, well then, in the name of friendship, however misguided, I have a date with Cliff this weekend. Uh, we're going to the carnival on Saturday.
Dawson: Is that what you didn't want to tell me? (He laughs.)
Quite frankly, I'm relieved.
Jen: You're relieved?
Dawson: The truth is I also have a date this weekend. And we're going to the carnival. Isn't that a coincidence?
Jen: Yeah, it is. You know, if you want us to go someplace else, we can easily change our plans.
Dawson: We shouldn't run away from these things. We should look at them as opportunities.
Jen: Opportunities for what?
Dawson: Um, a double date.
Jen: Are you serious?
Dawson: Of course I'm serious. What do you say? The four of us?
Jen: Well I say, it's a little unexpected...um, but, hey if you're cool with it.
Dawson: Completely. Yeah.
Jen: Okay. Great.
(Dawson walks away, hurt. The bell rings for the next class to begin.)
(Cut to the cafeteria where Dawson and Pacey are getting their lunches.)
Pacey: It's really not all that bad, Dawson. Remember how I told you about getting Jen back is a two step process?
Pacey: Well this is the second part.
Dawson: What? Humiliate myself at a amusement park?
Pacey: No, man, dating other women. This is your chance to have Jen see you in action with other girls. Now, I admit, going on a double date with your ex is an kind of an advance move. However, if it works out, this could be exactly the thing you're looking for.
Dawson: There's just one thing.
Pacey: What's that?
Dawson: My companion for Saturday is at this point fiction.
Pacey: That's really not a problem. I admit, it's kind of short notice but there are a lot of young ladies who'd gave up their very uneventful plans for a date with Dawson Leery. Huh?
Pacey: Besides, I think I have the perfect candidate right there.
(Pacey gestures toward Mary Beth who is sitting alone, reading a book. Dawson picks up his lunch tray and walks over to her.)
Dawson: Mary Beth?
Mary Beth: (looking up from her book) Oh, hi, Dawson.
Dawson: Mind if I join you?
Mary Beth: Oh no, be my guest.
(Dawson sets his tray down and sits down next to her.)
Dawson: Look, maybe this is short notice and if it is, then I apologize, but I was wondering if you wanted to, sort of go out with me on Saturday?
Mary Beth: Saturday? Like a date?
Dawson: Yeah, of course. Is there something wrong?
Mary Beth: No. Yeah. Well, yeah. it's just that, uh, I know that you just broke up with Jen. And well, I don't know the particulars of it all, I do know that it's a common mistake made by many people to begin to date before they're really ready.
Dawson: I'm ready. Completely ready. I could not be more ready.
Mary Beth: Honest?
(Cut to the biology class. Pacey and Joey are looking into an aquarium filled with snails.)
Pacey: Boy, this is fascinating.
Joey: I'm sorry there are no cartoons to make this interesting for you, Pacey. But it's not designed to be fascinating. It's designed to be educational.
Pacey: Thank you, Dr. Swissler. You know, refresh my memory of why we're here again.
Joey: We're observing the reproductive process of palominos snails. And Dr. Ram said that they reproduce more when they're happy so by varying the contents of the tank, we can determine which factors are most conducive to reproduction.
Pacey: Well, why didn't you just say that? We'll buy them a couple of drinks, turn off the light and come back in a couple of days.
Joey: You never fail to disappoint me, Pacey. I mean, why did I actually think the very real prospects of repeating Marine Biology next summer might cause you to take this project seriously.
Pacey: You mean, summer school? It will never happen. Only morons go to summer school.
Joey: Yeah, well the last time I checked, your grade is still an F minus. So, about this extra credit project, Pacey. I'm very well certain that your grade will not only place you squarely along with the morons but you may very well be there with them.
(Cut to Dawson's room. Dawson is at his desk looking at something under a magnifying glass. Mitch knocks on the door and enters.)
Mitch: Sorry to interrupt but I was just wondering if uh, anyone had called that I should know about.
Dawson: Uh, no.
Mitch: What about yesterday? Any calls?
Dawson: Come on. I always leave the messages or on the answering machine.
Mitch: Forgive me, Dawson, but maybe I'm not being clear. I didn't ask if anyone had called for me personally. I asked you if anyone had called that I should know about.
Dawson: No. He didn't call.
Mitch: Oh well, then. Thank you, Dawson.
(The next day. Joey and Pacey are in the biology classroom checking out the snails. Pacey has hands in the tank as Joey watches with an upset expression on her face.)
Joey: Pacey, it was your responsibility last night to check on these snails and now look at them. They're dead. Their shells are completely empty.
Pacey: I know. I'm sorry. I really am.
Joey: It's ridiculous. Yesterday, we had a science project and today, we have what? Two thirds of a charm bracelet? Look, I'm just going to tell Dr. Ram that this experiment within an experiment just isn't working out.
Pacey: Hey, before you go running off to Dr. Ram, there is an explanation. There is. Alright, you know how you said this experiment was all about seeing what environment was best for these snails? Right? So, I did come in last night and I was watching the snails and watching the snails and there's nothing happening. So, I added some food, and I added some water and there still was nothing happening. So I thought maybe the problem wasn't the environment, maybe these snails just didn't like each other. Right? Maybe they needed to be loosen up a little.
Joey: I told you yesterday that palominos snails are single sexed. They don't need anther organism to reproduce.
Pacey: Right and I would have remembered that if I actually listened when you talked. But, I just thought that maybe snails are just like guys. You know, their ultimate fantasy is to be with two female snails at the same time. Maybe that was what was needed to get this project rolling.
Joey: So, let me get this straight. You tried to create some kind of snail ménage-à-trois.
Pacey: Well, it sounds kind of stupid when you say it out loud but I just saw this really pretty snail in the tank over by the window and I don't know, but last night it just seemed really brilliant.
Joey: Let me fill you in on something here. You know, this pretty little snail over here by the window is what you call a carnivorous snail. You know what carnivorous snails eat?
Pacey: Other snails.
Joey: Yeah. Other snails. Other snails such as our snails which are the snails we are desperately relying on to raise our marine biology grades.
Pacey: Okay. I'm sorry. Okay? I know how important this project was for you. For us. Okay? Whatever I need to do, okay, however I can make this up to you, Joey.
(Dawson and Joey are walking from the creek to her house, carrying nets.)
Joey: I'm disappointed in you, Dawson. I mean, it's obvious that you're just using Mary Beth to make Jen jealous.
Dawson: I know. You think I don't know that Joey? I'm filled with the guilt of the worst kind. The kind that prays upon an innocent young girl who has a crush on you and you convince to go out with you for my own personal gain.
Joey: Well, if you know that, then don't do it. Just call her up and say you have to stay in to wash your hair or something.
Dawson: I can't, Joey. It's just I know the person I thought I was could have some consideration for Mary Beth's feelings and cancel the date but I don't know. I just. I don't feel like myself lately. You know? Anyway, Pacey said that I should look at this as an opportunity.
Joey: Wait a second. You're taking romantic advice from a guy who spent his evening trying to get three snails to sleep with each other?
Dawson: When you put it that way..
Joey: Look Dawson, your little departure into jerkism is understandable, perhaps. but it isn't something you should be proud of. Just promise you won't make a habit of it?
Dawson: Jo, I promise.
Joey: Because, despite current evidence to the contrary, you're one of the good ones, Dawson. The other side is populated enough.
Dawson: You know, all things considered, I really wish I was taking you with me today.
Joey: Well, all things considered, I kind of wish you were too.
(Pacey pulls up in his truck.)
Pacey: (leaning out of truck's the window) Come on, Joey, let's get a move on.
Joey: I see, my deviant lab partner has arrived. Pacey's graciously volunteered to transport me to the tidal pool so we can find a suitable replacement snails. See ya. (She gets into Pacey's truck.)
(Dawson is waiting at the front entrance of the carnival. Mary Beth walks up to him and greets him.)
Mary Beth: Dawson.
Dawson: Mary Beth, Hi.
Mary Beth: Hi. So it is too forward if I tell you that you look really nice?
Dawson: No, it's not. Thanks. So do you.
Mary Beth: Oh, no. You shouldn't feel obligated to say that. I mean...uh, I mean. I'm...ah. Let's just start over again. Hi, I'm Mary Beth.
Cliff: Perfect. Looks like we're just in time for introductions,
Dawson: Yeah. Mary Beth, this is Jen Lindley and Cliff, her date.
Jen: Hi, it's nice to meet you.
Mary Beth: Uh, same here, I think. Um, Dawson, a word, please?
Dawson: Uh, we'll catch up.
(Dawson and Mary Beth walk away from Jen and Cliff)
Mary Beth: This wasn't a freak coincidence, was it?
Dawson: A word? No.
Mary Beth: Look, maybe on our planet taking an ex-girlfriend on a double date is a good idea but where I come from, it's not. In fact, it's a lousy idea. Especially when you fail to inform your evening's companion.
Dawson: Look, it's not what you think.
Mary Beth: Before you tell me what you think, let me tell you. It's pretty obvious you're still hung up on her
Dawson: Mary Beth
Mary Beth: Please know that I'm often not wrong about these things.
Dawson: Until now.
Mary Beth: Humor me.
Dawson: Here's the absolute truth.
(Pacey and Joey are rowing down the creek)
Pacey: I've often regarded patrolling for snails as one of the more under-rated ways to spend one's evening.
Joey: You know, despite what you might think, it's not my first choice of spending my Saturday afternoon, either. But, then again, I wasn't the one who tried to turn an aquarium into a playhouse retreat, now was I?
Pacey: You know, actually Joey, I'm really curious about something. I thought you were this great student, so uh, what happened to you on this midterm, huh?
Joey: What do you mean what happened?
Pacey: What grade did you get? Was it a massive failure like mine or was it one of those near misses? I'm dying to know.
Joey: You know, we're almost there and we don't have a lot of time so let's just save the chit chat for later, OK?
(Mary Beth and Dawson are still having their Œword.')
Mary Beth: So, you're really doing this for Jen?
Mary Beth: Ah, it's one of her first dates with Cliff. She probably doesn't want to be alone with him so he doesn't really know if she likes him. So, in order to take the pressure off, she asks you to make it a double. God, Dawson, that is really very sweet of you.
Dawson: Really, don't mention it.
Mary Beth: I can imagine some of those guys even trying to sabotage their ex girlfriend's date.
Dawson: Really? That's terrible.
Mary Beth: Yeah, I know. So, anyway, what should we do now?
(Dawson looks down and sees Jen and Cliff at a game booth.)
Dawson: Um, I think I have an idea.
(Cut to Joey and Pacey are along the banks.)
Joey: Alright, Pacey, the water's getting pretty high, so we should probably... (she looks down to see their rowboat drifting away) Pacey!
Joey: Please tell me you tied our boat up and the one floating downstream is not ours.
(Pacey follows Joey's gaze is and sees their rowboat floating away.)
Pacey: I tied our boat up and the one floating downstream is not ours?
(Cut back to the carnival. Dawson, Mary Beth, Jen and Cliff are at the Bottle Throwing Booth. Cliff and Dawson are playing while Mary Beth and Jen are watching them)
Cliff: (as he knocks the last bottle down and wins) Aw, tough luck, Dawson.
Game Operator: And we got a winner.
Cliff: Alright. Which one?
Jen: Go ahead. You decide. I trust you.
(Cliff looks at all the stuffed animals and finds one he likes)
Cliff: Great. We'll take that one
Game Operator: The cat for the little lady.
Mary Beth: You know what? I think the Ferris wheel is working again, so...if anybody wants to take a ride?
Dawson: (motioning to Cliff) Once more, you and me
Cliff: What's that?
Dawson: You heard me. Rack 'em.
Cliff: Look, Dawson, there's no shame in losing here, alright? I mean, I did come in third in the pitch hit regionals last summer in Boston. So, if you don't want to.
(Dawson throws the ball knocking down a few balls)
Dawson: Your turn.
(Cliff takes his turn and then Dawson does. Mary Beth and Jen turn to each other.)
Dawson: (to Cliff) After you.
(Cliff throws the ball and misses the last bottle)
Cliff:.(just as Dawson is about to throw) Oh, and Dawson? No pressure now, alright?
(Dawson hits his last bottle and wins the game)
Game Operator: We got a winner here. So, my friend, who's the lucky lady?
(Dawson takes the stuffed animal and turns towards Jen, then to Mary Beth, not sure what to do)
Dawson: (to Mary Beth) Um, we need to talk.
(Back to the creek. Pacey and Joey are wadding through the creek trying to get themselves back to Pacey's truck.)
Pacey: Look, it's no big deal. The boat will wash ashore eventually.
Joey: You know, believe it or not, the boat isn't my first concern. I should have known that what you did with our snails, that I wouldn't be far behind. I'm freezing.
Pacey: Listen, it's just a little cold water, alright? You're going to survive. The prediction I make with all doom at this point.
Joey: Clever. Speaking of survival, I thought creatures of our level went extinct a few years back.
Pacey: You know, it's amazing. A personality like yours and you still can't get any dates.
Joey: Even more amazing. A personality like yours and you can.
(Pacey and Joey are at Pacey's truck. He grabs some blankets and hands one to Joey)
Pacey: We'll get some dry clothes when we drive over to your house. But for right now, just change into this.
Joey: (looking at the blanket) A blanket? You want me to change into a blanket?
Pacey: Yeah. Take off your wet clothes, wrap this around you like I'm going to do.
Joey: Wait a second. You want me to get naked?
Pacey: Please! This is not for my enjoyment. It's so you don't get sick. But if you got your heart set on pneumonia, then feel free pause And no peeking.
(They go to opposite sides of his truck and change.)
Joey: Oh yeah, the thrill of seeing you in your birthday suit is really my idea of a thrill.
Pacey: You know, a lot of people would consider you a very lucky woman.
Joey: And many people would consider you a very delusional man.
Pacey: Okay. All set over here. How are you doing?
(Pacey starts heading towards Joey.)
Joey: You take one more step in this direction and I can almost guarantee you a permanent disability.
Pacey: Tell you what? Why don't I just start the car?
Joey: Good idea.
(Pacey gets in the driver's side of the car gets comfortable. He glances in the rear view mirror to catch a sight of Joey undressing. Joey gets into the truck about a minute later. She looks at Pacey who is staring at her.)
Joey: What? What's that smile of yours? Is it because I look ridiculous?
Joey: Or is it my misfortune that amuses you? Maybe it's simply you enjoy putting me in the most awkward situations and just watching me squirm, Pacey?
Pacey: No, it's none of that. I was just. I was just thinking to myself that when you loosen up, you're not half bad to be around. Bordering on funny, even.
Joey: Holy geez.
Pacey: Yeah, just don't mention I said this.
(Pacey starts the car heads back to Joey's place.)
(Mary Beth is sitting on the hood of a car. Dawson sees her and walks over to her.)
Dawson: Mary Beth.
Mary Beth: Oh God, I'm so embarrassed. Good old Mary Beth, creating scenes wherever she goes.
Dawson: Mary Beth, I'm the one who should be embarrassed. I owe you an explanation. This time, I owe you the truth. You have every right to be upset with me because everything you said before, everything I convinced you wasn't the truth. Well it was. You were right. I'm not over Jen. Not the other way around. And I'm on this date not to help her but to get her back, I mean.
Mary Beth: Dawson? You're a nice guy. I like you. Do I like like you? No. You're a little too neurotic for that.
Dawson: Okay. Well, why did you go out with me?
Mary Beth: First, I felt sorry for you. I mean, it was clear you were still hung up on Jen. But I don't know, you seemed harmless enough and my Saturday wasn't exactly action packed.
Dawson: Okay. So, if it wasn't my feelings for Jen that upset you, then what was it Mary Beth?
Mary Beth: You ever notice the way's Cliff's eyes sort of smile when he talks to me?
Dawson: Oh, God! You have a crush on Cliff?
Mary Beth: It was at that moment that I fully processed he has absolutely no interest in me. He was totally hung up on Jen.
Dawson: He is?
Mary Beth: She's pretty hung up on him, too.
Dawson: She is?
Mary Beth: Afraid so.
Dawson: It's over.
Mary Beth: Of course, this doesn't mean we can't help each other out.
(Jen and Cliff are standing in line for the Ferris wheel in front of Dawson and Mary Beth.)
Cliff: (to Jen) You having a nice time, Jen?
Jen: Yeah. Yeah it's fun.
Dawson: (to Mary Beth) Alright. Let's do it!
Jen: Well, it looks like we're finally next.
Mary Beth: Perfect. So, Cliff, why don't you ride with me because we've hardly chatted all night.
(Mary Beth takes Cliff with her onto the Ferris wheel leaving Jen with Dawson, in confusion)
Dawson: Uh, we're next.
(Cut to Joey's house.)
Pacey: Thanks for the clothes, Jo.
Joey: Well, don't thank me. Thank Bodie, they're his.
Pacey: You know Joe. We're on dry land and you never did answer my question.
Joey: And what question was that?
(Joey walks into the kitchen and Pacey leans against the wall.)
Pacey: Well, your midterm grade. Listen, I know you're a little embarrassed so let me just remove the stigma. I got somewhere in the neighborhood of a 32.
Pacey: Come on, Joey, just cough it up.
Pacey: No? Then let me guess at it. 58? 38? 42?
Pacey: 98? Which one was it? 9 or 8?
Joey: Both of them, okay?
Pacey: Okay. I assume there's a suitable explanation for that story, Jo.
Joey: No explanation. Look around you, Pacey. Look at what my life is. I'm a boarder in my sister's house. I share my bedroom with the living room and my social life consists of a part time job. As far as I can tell, there are only two ways to make my life better. The one that doesn't involve waking up and discovering it's all been a dream involves a college scholarship. And when I apply, I better have the grades to not give them a choice because a scholarship is pretty much my only way out of Capeside. If I don't get out of here, Pacey, well, it would be a sadder story than I can imagine.
Pacey: Not to worry, Jo. You'll make it out of here. You'll go to a great school and send me postcards back here. I'll be tending bar or pumping gas.
Joey: Come on, Pacey. You'll get out.
Pacey: Well, the circus is hiring. Tell you what, though. I'm betting against the Potter girl.
(Dawson and Jen are sitting on the Ferris wheel)
Dawson: You having fun tonight or what?
Dawson: Is that a yes to the fun or a yes to the what?
Jen: To the fun
(The Ferris wheel stops and Dawson and Jen are left at the very top of the wheel.)
Jen: Oh, great.
Dawson: I'm sure they'll have it fixed in a minute.
(Mary Beth and Cliff are one car down from Dawson and Jen.)
Mary Beth: You want to know what's fascinating? That the word flammable and inflammable mean the same thing? Isn't that bizarre?
(Cliff gives Mary Beth a funny look.)
(Cut back to Jen and Dawson's car.))
Dawson: So, you and Cliff seem pretty together.
Jen: Oh, I wouldn't exactly say that.
Dawson: What would you say?
Jen: I would say that it's only a date. Um, I'd say we're just getting to know each other. I would also say that I don't think I want to talk about this with you anymore. (She pauses and thinks for a second.) Dawson, I know I made a big deal about our remaining friends with you and at the risk of sounding rude, I think I should retract my offer.
Dawson: What's that supposed to mean?
Jen: It means you shouldn't be here. I don't know why you wanted to come or why I let you but at this point in time, I really don't think that a seamless transition to friendship is in the cards for us, Dawson.
Dawson: Well, I'm not sure you'd have the time for me anyhow. What? With your dating schedule and all.
Jen: You know, I would love if we could get off this Ferris wheel without insulting each other anymore.
Dawson: Am I insulting you Jen?
Dawson: Is that what I'm doing? You know, because that's not my intent. My intent, since we suddenly have the time for, is for one small clarification.
Jen: What's that?
Dawson: Okay. When you broke up with me, one of the many questions I asked was why? Remember that? And do you remember your response? Your very convincing, very heartfelt response? You needed to be alone. There were too many men in your life and that you needed some time away from those men.
Jen: (quietly) Dawson. I didn't..
Dawson: Correct me if I'm wrong but Cliff Elliot is exactly what I'm talking about.
Jen: It's date. Alright? It's not like I'm planning our engagement party.
Dawson: Okay. Why didn't you just tell me the truth? Why didn't you just say what only now, much to my dismay and embarrassment, beginning to realize. That you weren't tired of men. You were simply just tired of me.
Jen: (softly) That is not true, Dawson. Alright. That is not true.
Dawson: Prove me wrong, Jen. Look at me and tell me that I was wrong and I completely misread the situation. Jen? Look at me.
("Hanging By a Thread² by Jann Arden begins playing until we see Dawson sees Pacey and Joey in the next scene)
Jen: Dawson, I don't want to get into this right now. Alright?
Dawson: You asked me two questions a minute ago and I'd like to answer them. First of all, why am I here? (Dawson pauses) All of the oblivious cliques about the ex boyfriend who's still hung up on his ex, who doesn't want to say good-bye, who can't let go. Why did you allow me to come? Could it be? Could it possibly be that your reason is the same as mine? That you need me just as much as I need you? (Dawson looks at Jen who looks like she's about to cry) Jen?
Dawson: Alright. Just don't tell me I was wrong.
(Dawson is sitting alone on a bench thinking to himself. ³Hanging By A Thread² continues to play in the background. He sees Joey and Pacey walking down the midway.)
Dawson: What are you guys doing here?
Joey: Just checking out some of the famed excitement.
Pacey: (to Dawson) Actually, I need to talk to you, Dawson.
Pacey: In private.
(Dawson and Pacey walk away from Joey, leaving her by herself and wondering what's so important. Dawson and Pacey in front of the Merry-Go-Around ride and talk.)
Pacey: Alright. So how did tonight go for you?
Dawson: Let me put it to you this way...terribly. You?
Pacey: (laughs) Not so bad, actually. Um, that's why I'm here to talk to you about. I want to ask your permission for something.
Pacey: Yeah. You know that Joey and I have never really particularly liked each other. Right? That's why it seemed like a bad idea when we got stuck together on that Marine Bio thing. Funny thing is, it wasn't. In some ways, and somewhere in there, I not only stopped disliking her so much, I began to sort of like her. As a friend.
Dawson: At first, At first, I realized your feelings for Joey are somehow firm beyond the friendship stage.
Pacey; That's good. Because that's exactly what I meant to imply.
Dawson: (laughing) You have the hots for Joey? Pacey, what are you like inhaling too many laugh chemicals? You and Joey are moral enemies.
Pacey: Dude, do you mind keeping your face down? This isn't exactly public knowledge at this point.
Dawson: You serious?
Dawson: (pauses) Okay. So you like Joey. Why do you need my permission?
Pacey: I don't know how to say this but I know that you two have this long tortured subtext together. I just don't want to. I want to make sure, that if I were to do something about this, like kiss her or whatever, that I wouldn't be stepping on any toes.
Dawson: You're my friend. And Joey's my friend. I don't care if who she kisses. And if it's you, so much the better. My two best friends, kissing, what could be better than that?
Pacey: Great. So you're cool with this, then
Pacey: Alright, Dawson, see you later.
(Pacey turns to walk away from Dawson.)
Dawson: No! wait. I'm not cool with this.
(Pacey turns back around and looks at Dawson)
Pacey: You're not?
Pacey: Okay. So what do we do about now?
Dawson: Nothing. Nothing. You know what. Because I am fine with it. A momentary lapse there. I couldn't be. I couldn't be more fine. Yeah Go for it. Kiss her. Go ahead. You have my blessing.
Pacey: You sure this time?
Dawson: Absolutely. I definitely am.
(³She's the One² by World Party is playing as Joey and Pacey pull up to Joey's house. Pacey walks Joey to the bottom of the steps and VERY close to her.)
Pacey: So, Am I going to have to fail another midterm or can we do this again sometime?
Joey: Well, we still have to finish our report, Pacey, but I'm pretty sure we'll be spending a lot of time together.
Pacey: Actually, that's not what I was talking about, Joey.
Joey: Then, what did you mean?
Pacey: Well, let me put it to you this way.
(Pacey leans over and kisses Joey. Joey backs away in disgust)
Joey: Pacey! Pacey! What the hell was that?
Pacey: Well, if I have to explain myself, it really didn't have the desired effect.
Joey: Why in the world would? I mean, I guess I know why you would but why would you?
Pacey: Why would I? Because I had a really nice time today, a nice time that exceeded my wildest expectations. I was, I was confused and surprised and attached. You?
Joey: Well, confused and surprised.
Pacey: Not? (pauses) Okay. I can deal with rejection pretty effortlessly. So long as we don't drag this really awkward moment out any longer than we have to.
Joey: Good night, Pacey. I had a nice time, too. See ya.
(Joey walks up to her front door.)
(Joey turns and looks back at Pacey.)
Pacey: By some slim chance, that you would actually kiss me back, you'd be probably thinking of somebody else, right?
(Joey turns slowly back and walks inside.)
(Cut to Dawson's room. He is laying down on his bed and ³She's the One² begins playing again. Suddenly he gets up and goes downstairs to see his parents dancing. Dawson stops for a second to watch them. The phone rings. Gail gently starts to push Mitch away to pick it up.)
Mitch: Let it ring.
(Dawson leaves for the video store.)
(Cut to the video store where Pacey is working. He is watching The Three Stooges when Dawson enters. Pacey turns the TV off to talk to him)
Dawson: I figured you'd be here. So, uh, listen. About what we talked about before? About what you asked me? I changed my mind. I don't want you to do it.
Pacey: (as he puts away videos behind the counter) You're going have to refresh my memory so we're on the same page here.
Dawson: You know what we're talking about, Pacey.
Pacey: Joey. You don't want me to kiss Joey. You seem a little worked up here, Dawson, I don't know how to break it to you
Dawson: Break what to me?
Pacey: Well, you're a little late.
Dawson: You kissed her.
Pacey: Oh yeah. Not only that, she kissed me back. Right there on the front side of the Witter Family truck. We played tonsil hockey for about an hour. She invites me in but it was getting a little late so I didn't. But she's cooking for me tomorrow night, she says she always wanted to cook for the right man. You should come. We're thinking about heading up to this cozy little B and B up the coast and spending some quality time this weekend.
(Pacey makes a clicking sound with his tounge)
Dawson: You're so full of it.
Pacey: *Yes I am.* And so are you. You know, it's time you start asking yourself some serious questions, Dawson. Because you exhaust way too much time and energy on a girl you call your friend. So, you know what? Let's just set the record straight here. Who's it going to be? Is it Jen or is it Joey? Do you like the blond or do you like the brunette? These questions are not going to go away, Dawson. It's time you provide some answers.