01x01 - They Looked Like Cops

[bunniefuu]

[wind howling]

[traffic noise in distance]

[eerie music playing]

[man] The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum

was a art thief's delight.

[suspenseful music plays]

Everybody talks about the Gardner.

This is this is it.

The biggest art theft

in the history of the world.

Millions of dollars' worth of artwork.

They disappeared.

Somebody had to know something.

[blows smoke out]

[man 2] Every reporter in this town

eventually did something on that heist.

We were all hitting our sources

saying, "What's up?"

People didn't seem to know.

[engine revving]

[man 3] The crime occurred in 1990

on St. Patty's Day.

Whatever drunken revelry was occurring

across the city, who knows?

Happy St. Patty's Day.

[man 3] But it was a good time

to commit a crime.

- [motorcycle engine revs]

- [siren wails]

[woman 1] With this case,

it is really Boston's

biggest unsolved mystery,

in addition to being

the largest art heist in the world.

Everybody has a theory.

The people that did it

maybe they're dead.

Maybe some who were involved

are still alive.

When I start to think about

the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum

and the drama and the obsession

with getting the paintings back

and the whole obsession

around everything,

I keep talking about it

because it's fascinating to me,

because I was there.

[clock ticks]

[Clougherty] I was a witness.

[clock machinery whirring]

[atmospheric music playing]

[Clougherty] That night,

I had plans to meet friends.

It was quiet on Palace Road.

The street's very dark

just lit by this really faint amber glow

from the streetlights.

We were outside the building

and I asked my friend Justin,

"Can you give me a piggyback ride?"

Jumped on,

and we started walking down the street.

[Stratman] We're goofing around,

we'd had beers,

and I noticed that this car

has its running lights on.

We're coming from behind it.

When I get up close to it,

I see that there are people in it.

[Clougherty]

Two men in the front seats.

[Stratman]

There's a glare from a streetlamp,

but I can see the shoulder

of a policeman's uniform.

Boston police uniform,

it's got a sort of distinctive

keystone shape.

[Clougherty]

When we saw the officer,

thinking at that time

that they had come to end the party,

our feeling was, "Let's just go."

I do remember that the car was parked

right next to the Gardner Museum.

I probably wouldn't have

remembered this night [chuckles]

if it hadn't been for

what happened later.

[VCR machinery creaking]

[dramatic music playing]

[man 1]

The biggest art heist in history.

[intricate orchestral music]

Boston, a quiet museum, a daring robbery.

[man 2] Vipers are in the grass

and are moving towards you.

[man 3] The 13 art treasures stolen

are worth a half a billion dollars.

Take a look at these composite drawings.

[man 4]

I have the paintings with me. Now what?

[man 5]

Easy to use as international currency.

[woman 1] Japan.

- [man 2] France.

- [man 5] Dublin.

[man 6] Saudi Arabia.

I know that's where they went.

[woman 2] These paintings were

a get-out-of-jail-free card,

and everybody knew it.

[man 7] How are those paintings

gonna get people out of prison?

What are we talking about this sh*t for?

[woman 2] Who could carry off

something like this?

[man 5]

Italian mob or Irish mob.

- How you doing?

- Good.

[man 4]

Everybody is whacked.

[woman 2] There's murders

on both sides, it's violent.

- [expl*si*n]

- Jesus!

As long as you didn't do anything,

you got nothing to worry about.

[woman 1]

I had no idea what I was going into.

It was just horrifying.

[man 8] For now, the empty frames

are all that remain on the museum walls.

[atmospheric music playing]

[Anne Hawley] With works of art,

they're only works of art

because you're interacting with them.

I mean, they can't exist without you.

I was the director

of the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum

from 1989 to 2016,

and the first woman to be a director.

The museum had become inward-looking.

It hadn't connected deeply

to the community.

So, I was brought in

to bring the museum back to life,

was sort of my charge.

[Shelley Murphy] I grew up in Dorchester.

I went to South Boston High School.

And the first time I went,

I fell in love with the place.

I had been through all the galleries

and I can remember so vividly

The Storm on the Sea of Galilee.

Loving that one in particular.

This is gonna make me sound like

a wicked snob, and I'm not.

It's sort of like the MFA in Boston

was like the Louvre,

and the Gardner Museum

was like the d'Orsay.

So pretentious,

I can't believe I said it.

Has more character. Put it that way.

[Hawley]

It's such a beautiful environment

that you go to another place.

I like to call it the "a-ha" moment

or the epiphanic moment,

which is a little too heady to say.

It's built to echo

a Renaissance Venetian palace.

It's very plain on the outside.

You're just shocked when you come inside

to this verdant, luscious courtyard

that is at the center of the museum,

and all the galleries

on every floor surround it.

And then every gallery

has its own theme.

It's probably one of the most

extraordinary creations

by an individual anywhere.

When Isabella Stewart Gardner

built the museum,

she broke ground in 1899.

There was nothing here.

It was a swamp.

And when she died,

she left her infamous will.

She said that if anything

were permanently changed,

the collection should be crated,

shipped to Paris for auction,

and the money should go

to Harvard University.

She was an eccentric

in a world where being eccentric

was a way of getting out of the house

for women.

[bright, inquisitive music plays]

[Vigderman] I believe she was flirtatious.

She didn't mind being a little sexy.

And she dressed to show it off.

Which, you know, wasn't part of the time.

Before the museum was open,

she wanted to test the acoustics,

but you have to have people in the room

listening to the music.

But she didn't want anybody

to see the place.

She was connected

to the Perkins School for the Blind

and she had the blind children come in

and be the bodies listening to the music

to test the acoustics.

You know, it's not a museum.

It was her work of art.

It's an architectural spectacle.

[Karen Sangregory] To this day, I still

have dreams about the Gardner Museum.

All of that stuff really seeped in.

As a gallery guard,

we had all this time to spend

intimate time with the collection.

There's no downside to working

in a Venetian palace.

It was just beautiful.

We had the Titian r*pe of Europa.

We had the Raphael,

Matisse,

Rembrandt.

And it was just that whole environment.

To feel like you could reach out

and touch something

from that long ago.

Here I am, staring at the actual marks

made by the actual hand

of this guy when he was, like, my age.

You just can't get any better than that.

[Aaron Fannin]

If you got the call

to work overnight shift,

you were happy to do it.

It was kind of a treat.

You were like,

"Cool. I get to go stay all night."

All the lights in the museum were off,

and you just had your flashlight

and a walkie-talkie.

You'd do your round,

walk through the museum.

It was pretty spooky.

And then you'd sit at the desk

and wait for something to happen.

And

nothing ever happened.

[Heidorn]

That's the problem of the night watch.

Day after day, week after week,

year after year of nothing happening.

Just absolute benign Nothing happening.

And then March 18th, 1990.

[reporter] Today is Sunday,

March 18th, 1990.

A beautiful day in South Boston.

Now, as the parade gets underway,

it's 48 degrees.

We'll see a high of 52 and clear skies.

[Cullen]

St. Patrick's Day in Boston,

the day itself,

I'd call it just a drinking day.

People'd be drinking all day,

rolling into Saturday,

then right into Sunday.

And Boston has its parade on Sunday.

It's not on the 17th.

The parade in Boston

is confined to South Boston.

It draws in hundreds of thousands

of people from outlying areas.

Quick march!

The other thing, it would attract

an enormous police presence.

[siren squawking]

But in the area where the museum is,

it's generally quiet.

[Sangregory]

It was a total normal day.

Just coming in to work

on Sunday morning in my role

to replace the two guys

that would've been there all night

at the alarm control center desk.

[phone rings]

Normally, one or both of them would be

in there and they would buzz us in.

Nothing like that was happening.

There was no response,

this was completely unprecedented

and very odd.

[suspenseful music plays]

Too much time is passing.

So, I called the chief of security

and told him we couldn't get in.

He said, "I'm coming in."

He took us around

some kind of a back door.

As soon as we got in there,

you just knew

something is really, really wrong.

The security cameras had been turned,

the office door had been busted.

There was a frame in there.

It was like, "Oh."

And there was a crowbar

leaning against the wall.

The chief hands me the crowbar.

He's like, "Here, hold this!"

And so I'm holding this crowbar

and my mind is thinking,

"This is part of the scene

of the crime, right?

This is evidence. My hand prints

My hand prints are on this crowbar!"

And then my next thought was,

"He gave me this so that

I can pummel someone with it."

It's like I went in with this open vision

and curiosity, like,

"Whoa!"

And then it just, like [whooshes]

shrunk down really fast.

And then it was like,

"Where's the guys? Where's the guys?"

And then the next thought was,

"Are the bad guys still here?"

He picks up the phone

and called the Boston police.

[sirens echoing]

It seemed like all he could say was,

"I'm calling from the Gardner.

[panting] We've got big trouble.

We've got big trouble."

[kettle whistling]

[Hawley]

Must have been about eight o'clock.

We had some friends

come over for breakfast

when I got the phone call

from the security director.

And he said,

"There's been a theft

and you need to come right now."

[indistinct radio chatter]

To me, it felt instantaneous.

Like, the street was lined with cars.

I ended up sitting

at the alarm control center.

And the police come in,

and it was the first order of business

to plop down this big box of donuts

on the counter.

Right in front of me. Like, "Whoo!"

[indistinct police radio chatter]

[Sangregory]

They went up and worked their way down.

No one knows what's going on.

We don't know where the guards are yet.

I had never done the rounds

like the night guards had,

but I had heard there were tunnels

under this building.

And I'll never forget

this astonished look

on the cop's face, and he says,

"Oh my God.

If there's a body to be found,

it'll be in a tunnel."

[ominous music plays]

As it turned out, the guards were located

down in the basement.

Tied up in the duct tape and everything.

The day of the robbery

was the first and last time

I was ever at the Gardner Museum.

I was a forensic photographer,

and I was also

an image analyst for the FBI.

I may have gotten there about 9:15 or so.

Those shots there were taken by BPD.

They photographed Rick.

Randy was in the other shot.

But they seemed to concentrate on Rick

and how he was taped up.

He was duct taped.

His head and his hair

in a roundabout fashion.

And then his hands were bound.

Which I thought was kind of odd.

They had a little pad.

Why would you tape around the head?

Why not just put tape on his eyes?

I've seen people who were k*lled.

They were taped.

But Rick's taping,

I never saw anything like that.

I thought that was kind of odd

that he was taped in that fashion.

We were thinking, "Jeez,

if these were any real serious hoods,

why not just k*ll these people?"

Dead men tell no tales.

[dramatic, moody music playing]

[man] Wait a minute. Go ahead.

[Hawley]

I think I got there around 8:30, maybe,

or quarter to 9:00.

I can't remember exactly.

The FBI was there,

and they wouldn't let me in

to any of the galleries,

so I had no idea what I was going into.

And when I got into the galleries,

it was just

- [slams door]

- horrifying.

[woman] Did you think you would be

- [man 1] How's that?

- [man 2] Good.

- [indistinct chatter]

- No.

[Green] When I first entered,

I saw the golden frames

overlapping one another.

And you could see

that someone had used a knife.

The paintings weren't unscrewed

from the back, they were cut out.

I found that pretty interesting.

Why did they cut them?

It wasn't like cutting a piece of paper.

As the conservators explained,

the paintings are not just one canvas.

You can't cut them out

and then roll them up like blueprints.

They said it'd be time-consuming

and difficult cutting these things.

[Sangregory] We were starting

to hear things, like, "What?

They just cut this stuff

out of the frames?

[grunts] Oh my gosh."

It was, and it still is,

completely unbelievable.

It was incomprehensible to me

that even if you were wanting to steal art

that you would treat it that way.

[indistinct speech]

[Hawley] There were 13 works

that were taken altogether.

In terms of art historical works,

the most important work lost

is the Rembrandt seascape,

Storm on the Sea of Galilee.

It's Rembrandt's only seascape,

and that was

brutally cut out of the frame.

As was the Rembrandt portrait

of The Lady and Gentleman in Black.

That was also cut out of the frame,

and that picture had been altered

at some time in the past.

There was a man and a woman,

and a space between them.

When they X-rayed it,

there was a child

between the man and the woman.

Apparently, the child died,

and it was too painful,

and it was painted out by Rembrandt.

The Vermeer picture's called The Concert.

And you have a woman

just about to burst into song.

Vermeer's paintings,

there aren't that many.

Some say 33, some say 35.

For me, that Vermeer was

the toughest one to realize,

"Boy, that thing is gone."

As a guard,

that was one of my favorite pieces

to just study.

You could just be there

and you could just almost like talk to it.

And then, of course, there was the Flinck,

Obelisk in the Landscape.

The Chinese beaker.

That actually was the oldest work taken.

Those were the works

that were in the Dutch Room,

along with an etching of Rembrandt.

The Rembrandt self-portrait

was also off the wall.

And I thought, "Oh my God, that too?"

And I pulled the frame out

and the picture was still there.

Then, from the Short Gallery,

there were five works on paper.

Degas depicting jockeys riding horses,

beautifully drawn and ex*cuted.

And then, in that same gallery,

the Napoleonic finial

from the Napoleonic flag.

They kinda theorized that that's where

probably they were out of time.

Where they tried to unscrew the finial.

The, uh, screws were in

the cigarette receptacle.

They hadn't gotten through

taking all the screws out,

so they figured it was time to go,

that these particular items

may have just been an afterthought.

And then finally,

from the first floor, the Blue Room,

a Manet called Chez Tortoni.

[Heidorn] There are

significant paintings missing.

Ballpark figure on the cost

is about $200 million.

[Hawley] The FBI didn't have

an art squad. Nobody did.

It was just devastating.

[reporter] Uh, in terms of the rooms

[Hawley] So, they were struggling

to get up to speed on it.

And, of course, we were shattered.

It was like a death in the family.

[reporter] That's precisely why people

I was just totally numb.

[Arnold Hiatt] We were told by the FBI

we needed to get a reward going

before the trail gets cold.

That was considered to be

the most important move we could make.

So, I called someone I knew

who was in the Philippines at the time.

He was also the chairman of Sotheby's.

"What do you want from me?" he said.

And I told him we needed

a million dollars.

Sotheby's and Christies stepped in,

offering this million-dollar reward.

[multiple phones ringing]

We were just overcome

with calls coming in.

The phone system broke down.

[ringing continues]

A group of us

were just really around the clock

working to get the reward out.

I operate under the assumption

that we are going to return

Get these returned,

because we are a world-class museum.

[Hawley] The press was brutal for a while.

Just brutal.

[reporter]

How long have you been director?

For six months.

- [reporter 2] Guards, how old were they?

- I don't know.

- How long have they worked for you?

- Do you know? I don't know.

[reporter 3] What happened?

Would you say that the guards

screwed up in this thing?

Or were they taken advantage of?

The FBI's handling all of that.

We will

I don't have more to say now,

but we will continually update you

if there is any new information.

[tense music playing]

[Tron Brekke] I was there that morning.

And I think I was maybe

the first FBI agent on the scene.

Boston PD was already there.

This was designated as a major theft,

and I had responsibility

for the violent crimes program,

which included

kidnappings, bank robberies,

fugitives, that type of thing.

As I recall,

they showed me the security area

that had been breached.

These guys obviously had some idea

of what they were doing.

[tense music continues]

I had to sit down

with the supervisor of the squad

that would handle violent crime like this.

We tried to figure out,

"What do we do? Who do we look at?

Where could these things have gone?"

I only saw the guards briefly upstairs.

There were other people

that were interviewing them

in this conference room.

I could see on the security camera

looked like two cops out there.

They come to the door, they rang the bell,

and they said,

"Boston Police. We got a report

of a disturbance on the premises."

I buzzed them in.

[door buzzing]

They asked me if I was alone,

and I said that no,

my partner was off doing a round.

They said, "Get him down here."

The cop turned to me and said,

"Don't I know you? Don't I recognize you?

I think there's a warrant out

for your arrest.

Can you step out from behind the desk?"

And he said, "Up against the wall."

The guy who was dealing with me

was taller and skinny

was wearing these gold frame

round glasses, if I remember correctly.

He had a mustache.

It looked really greasy.

It was probably a fake mustache.

And he handcuffed me.

Cuffed my partner.

Very dramatically said,

"Gentlemen, this is a robbery."

[reporter]

The FBI released these pictures

after conversations with guards

at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum.

[reporter] Suspect number one

is described as a white male

in his early 30s,

approximately 5'10" tall, 160 pounds,

dark hair,

and wearing gold wire-rim glasses.

Suspect number two is described

as a white male in his early 30s also.

Approximately 6" tall with dark hair.

I don't think the sketches

was that reliable.

How long did they see them?

Did they get a good look?

Were they wearing fake mustaches?

Take a look at these composite drawings.

They may, in a manner of speaking,

be worth several hundred million dollars.

If, that is,

they bear a striking resemblance

to the two men who inspired them.

[Brekke] With something like this,

we try to take a minute,

step back and say,

"Okay, where do we go from here?"

This is not a crime of opportunity.

These guys were not dressing up

for Halloween in policeman's uniforms

saying, "Gee, a good idea, let's go rob

the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum."

You know, this was planned out.

[Robert Fisher] A lot of planning.

They had duct tape, handcuffs, uniform on.

They were ready to get in.

I've done organized crime cases for years.

I've done wiretaps.

I think I know

how criminals think and act.

- I don't think it was a cold call.

- [door slams]

You analyze the 13 pieces

that were stolen.

It just seemed like they had

either cased the place

or given specific information

about what to look for,

what's on our shopping list.

A finial off the Napoleonic flag?

[Fisher]

It's confounding.

It's hard to figure out

why you would, in a museum,

with priceless pieces of art,

waste precious time with this finial

that is essentially worthless.

[Brekke]

They had taken a Chinese artifact.

[Fisher] A Chinese ku.

It's old, it's somewhat valuable,

but not even close to some of the other

items of art just in that room.

Was the Chinese artifact a diversion?

There was one self-portrait of Rembrandt

where his eyes follow you around the room.

They tried to steal that

and they took it down off the wall,

and for some reason, it was left behind.

And they don't know if it was

just too big or they forgot it.

[Fisher] One thing that stuck out

was the Rembrandt etching.

It's the size of a postage stamp.

The frame isn't much bigger.

And yet somebody wasted time

unscrewing that

and then taking apart the whole frame

and taking only the etching.

Right, if you're carrying out

the biggest heist in history

and you dunno

if the police are coming,

and you have limited time

to get valuable artwork,

are you gonna waste time

with an etching that isn't that expensive,

waste precious moments

taking it out of a frame

that you could

stick in your pocket regardless?

I would say no.

[Brekke] The paintings themselves,

everybody knows about it

so you can't sell 'em on the market.

At least not on the open market.

Sold, 43 million.

[reporter] Even at a time

when prices are setting records,

dealers and curators say these paintings

would be difficult to fence.

Many believe they were hired

to steal what they took.

But unless they had a buyer

already lined up,

it may have been one of the dumber

robberies in recent history.

[reporter 2]

Given that these pieces are well-known,

who could possibly keep them?

That's a very good question.

Only probably a person who is determined

to keep them private

for the rest of their life.

[reporter 1]

Some masterpieces are so valuable,

they may be too hot to sell.

Which raises the question:

were these thieves

working for a collector?

[Brekke]

The Storm on the Sea of Galilee

is the only seascape

that Rembrandt ever painted.

Who is gonna have that

in their living room?

We started speculating.

"Well, maybe it's a oligarch in Russia,

and he's got it in his basement

and he goes down there

and he looks at it."

You know, the only Rembrandt seascape

in existence.

A lot of people have speculated

that it was a Dr. No theory.

[Monty Norman's

"James Bond Theme" playing]

Some rich oil baron or billionaire

wanted these particular items,

and they paid a crew

to carry out the robbery.

[Fisher] It's somebody probably looks like

a villain from one of the Bond movies.

He's sitting there with his cognac

and his trophy wife

or girlfriend next to him

admiring the art that was stolen

from the Gardner.

I was the unwanted child

of a German missionary

and a Chinese girl of good family.

Any thought that these paintings

are hung on the walls of Mr. Big

who has them stolen to order

is utter rubbish.

The problem with your Dr. No theory

is that as soon as he's commissioned it,

and the thieves see there's,

in the case of the Gardner Museum,

a reward for information

leading to the recovery,

what are they gonna do?

They're gonna cash in.

They're gonna set the guy up

and get their reward.

[chuckles] No.

Dr. Nos and so on don't exist.

You get some

very professional criminals.

But they don't know how to handle art,

what to do with art.

And that's usually their undoing.

Where you've got a professional art thief,

the theft is professional, it's skilled.

The artwork has been taken

because they know

how they're gonna dispose of it.

That's when you've got a problem.

[tides rolling in]

My name is Steven George Xiarhos.

I'm the deputy chief of police

here in Yarmouth.

Yarmouth is historic, quaint, quiet.

And, looking back,

a good place to commit a crime.

So, in '88,

I get called out to this scene.

Pulling up to this beautiful museum,

the Bangs Hallet House,

and seeing the immediate aftermath

of a really serious crime.

They went in the back door,

they overpowered the caretaker,

tied her up,

taped her mouth shut, her eyes,

then stole all of these items.

They knew what they were looking for,

they had been inside,

and they were very successful.

And then disappeared.

So you start putting pieces together.

You work with local police,

and then state police, and then federal.

And through all that, that name came up,

this man named Myles Connor.

[camera flash pops]

[reporter 1] Myles Connor,

a legendary outlaw from Massachusetts.

[reporter 2] In 1975, he stole a Rembrandt

from the Museum of Fine Arts.

[dramatic music playing]

[man] I first met him,

I believe it was in Mattapan Square,

when he had either a cougar

or a mountain lion on a leash.

[growling]

I said, "That's Myles Connor."

And I introduced myself.

And I followed his career.

And then got to represent him.

Myles was the man.

He could play the guitar and sing.

And he put on a great show.

He might've been really a big star,

but everything always was interrupted

by his other activities.

Myles Connor.

Yeah. He did a show at the

- [man] The Beachcomber?

- Yeah, exactly that.

[tides rolling in]

[hip bass line playing]

My wife in her younger days

would go there

with her sisters and a few friends

and see his shows.

He was a robber, a thief

a k*ller.

[Myles Connor Jr.]

Depends upon whom you ask,

but in general,

I'm known as an art thief.

And some people

consider me the biggest art thief

in this country

because I've robbed a number of museums.

But then again,

I was a rock and roll guy.

Smoke rainbows

The halo out ♪

[Leppo] Myles Joseph Connor Jr.

His father was a police officer,

his step-brother

was a state police officer,

his other brother is a priest.

His favorite line was,

"Where did they go wrong?"

He was a criminal.

He was this 5'7 ", 5'8" guy

with this booming voice.

He was a member of Mensa,

he was like, brilliant.

[man] He has a doctor's knowledge

of human anatomy,

and is a student of Eastern philosophy.

[Murphty] He was always pulling off

crazy capers and getting into trouble.

Anybody in law enforcement

that hears my name,

I'm sure must think that I'm running

second neck-to-neck to Attila the Hun.

[Murphy] He robbed museums up in Maine,

he had shootouts with police.

[g*nshots]

Myles was shot three, four, five times

at once.

And went through surgery

without anesthesia.

[Murphy] He was the definition,

the quintessential art thief.

[Xiarhos]

When this crime happened in Yarmouth,

we tried to find him.

One day, I'm in my office

and I get a phone call.

"Detective,

I heard you were looking for me.

My name is Myles Connor."

He said, "Yes, that's my thing,

but I want you to know

I had nothing to do with this."

No one really saw anything,

but the cop in me wants to lock him up.

[Connor]

Take a peek here if you want to.

One, two, three, four, five, six, seven,

eight, nine.

No, I think that's wrong.

Actually 11 to 12. [laughs]

You lose count.

When the Gardner Museum happened,

yeah, we thought back to this.

It wasn't too long after, you know.

Whoever did this, that's their world.

Art theft.

It's not like breaking into a house

and stealing a TV.

This is different.

Whoever did this and Gardner,

in my opinion, may be connected.

They absolutely have done it before,

they probably did it again,

and that's professional thieves.

[man] How many art heists have you done?

[Connor] Probably 30. Thirty-plus.

[man] How many

did the authorities know about?

[Connor] Very little.

He was so well-prepared to do something.

You just don't go into a museum

and decide to take a painting.

It's the getaway

that's the big thing here.

And Myles was a great escape artist.

He had always said, not necessarily to me,

that the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum,

that that was on his bucket list.

Any reasonable person on the planet

would assume

that you masterminded it

from the beginning.

Myles Connor,

the biggest art thief in the city.

He would be suspect number one.

If he wasn't in jail

at the time that this happened

On the day of the robbery

of the Gardner Museum,

I was in federal custody.

[man] The FBI nailed him in a sting

involving art he'd stolen years before.

The judge gave him 11 years.

Which means that when the Gardner

was hit in 1990,

the master thief Myles Connor

was behind bars.

But there's a saying that the guards came

and knocked on my cell door

to make sure I was there.

But I think that's more legend

than it is fact.

[eerie music playing]

[Murphy]

I think there was a feeling

that somehow

this would shake out fairly quickly.

And then as time dragged on,

they realized this stuff was just

way too hot to handle,

that it was gonna take some time.

[Fisher] I started in Public Corruption

March of 2010.

My first week was the 20th anniversary.

It was a cold case, it was 20 years old,

so I took time going back through,

looking at other angles.

I wanna take this through step by step

how it happened.

Not only minute by minute,

but second by second.

How did this thing play out?

And how many things had to go right

for these two robbers

to still not be caught?

[Murphy] What we know

is that 23-year-old Richard Abath,

sort of a music school dropout,

is on duty that night.

Maybe around midnight or so,

Rick Abath takes the first shift

to do the rounds upstairs.

He says there were fire alarms going off,

and that he ends up

shutting off the fire alarm.

He comes down and relieves

the other guard at the desk.

But what he does is

he opens the outside door

and shuts it about 10 minutes

before the thieves show up.

[Fisher] The first thing we know

is that outside door

that they entered through

was open 15, 20 minutes

before they enter it.

Why?

[Murphy] So, now at 1:24 a.m.,

two men dressed as police officers

show up at the door.

They say they're there

to investigate a disturbance.

Rick Abath says he buzzed the door

and let them in.

[door buzzes]

They say, "I might have a warrant

for your arrest. Step away from the desk."

Now he's removed himself

from the only place

where he can get help from the outside.

There's a button

that will alert Boston Police

that there's a problem at the museum.

And now the thieves spend

81 minutes in the museum,

helping themselves.

[Fisher] Ten minutes in a robbery

seems like an eternity.

That's what has always stood out for me,

the fact they were comfortable enough

to be in there for 81 minutes.

That's an incredibly long time to spend

when you have people tied up

and you don't know if police are coming.

[Murphy] Another peculiar thing.

In the Dutch Room,

there was a secret panel.

There's a door that leads downstairs,

and it was slightly ajar

when the investigators

arrived that morning.

Which also raised the question,

who'd know there was a door?

[Fisher] There were security cameras,

but the thieves knew

where the VHS system was,

so they took tape from that evening.

We know that at least one

of the proximity detectors went off.

I think the Rembrandt.

[alarm wailing]

If an alarm like that goes off,

typically they get out of there,

in case that alerted somebody.

But these thieves didn't.

I don't see how this was pulled off

without inside information.

[sinuous string music playing]

My understanding is at the guard desk,

there was an old printer there

that prints out

the motion detector alarms.

Somebody took that.

They took the printout, the paper.

But it was 1990,

so they probably didn't realize

that there was a hard drive somewhere

that had the data.

[Murphy] The most peculiar thing about

what happened during those 81 minutes

is that most of the stolen artwork

was taken from the Dutch Room.

There were also some items

taken from the Short Gallery.

The Chez Tortoni

is the only piece

that was stolen on the first floor,

from the Blue Room.

And the only person

that the hard drive can show

whose steps went into that room

[whirring]

[beeping]

[tires screech]

were those of Richard Abath

when he was doing his rounds

in the museum.

[Fisher] Best we can tell in the data,

they never entered that room.

So, that means somebody

either took it off the wall before

or after the police got there.

["Intruder" by Peter Gabriel playing]

I know ♪

Something about ♪

Opening windows and doors ♪

I think it happened before the robbery.

I know ♪

How to move quietly ♪

To creep across creaky wooden floors ♪

Number one,

you've gotta look at the inner circle.

I know ♪

Where to find precious things ♪

In all your cupboards and drawers ♪

[Murphy]

Looking at it through today's lens,

the question is,

"Whoa, why wasn't there immediately

a lot of focus on Richard Abath?"

[Abath] Once I sat down with the FBI,

I I knew.

I was like,

"I'm the guy who opened up the door.

They're gonna be looking at me."

[intense string music playing]