Welcome to our World! Where we serve you cookies to ensure you get the best viewing experience on our site.

Did you know that you can remove censorship board-wide, use our advanced search functions, be notified when new content is posted, join our memberships, set episodes to show in any order you want & more if you are logged into your account?

Register or sign in here: ucp.php?mode=register

04x02 - Strong Kitty

Episode transcripts for the TV show, "Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story". Aired: September 21, 2022 – present.*
Watch/Buy Amazon


The story of one of the most notorious serial K*llers in the United States, largely told from the points of view of his victims.

04x02 - Strong Kitty

Post by bunniefuu »

["mangetout" by Wet Leg playing]

♪ Nice try ♪

♪ Get out the way ♪

♪ You're in our way... ♪

[growls]

[woman] I've got a new Irish girl too.
Orla's her name.

She's a real hedge wh*re, she is.

You can tell the way
she's always shaking her back avenue.

They're all pinchcocks, these Irish girls.

All they think about is
getting a pearly shower

from some fella's big old truncheon.

Always looking to join giblets
with somebody's husband.

They're more fertile than whites,
the Irish.

That's why they breed like rabbits.

Maggie, where is our luncheon?

Right here, Madame.

Voilà.

Ooh!

- What is that?
- [Maggie] This is called fiddlehead ferns.

The month of May
is the only season you can get them.

And those... those are crayfish.

I caught them fresh this morning

and I've simmered it
with butter and wild garlic.

Bon appétit.

[cracking]

[slurping]

- [woman] Mmm!
- [dry chuckle]

[cracking]

[woman chuckles]

[slurping]

Hang on to this one, Abby. [chuckles]

This Paddy can cook.

Hmm.

Delectable, Maggie.

Aren't you full of surprises?

How lovely.

I didn't know
of your love for fresh seafood.

I will think of a summertime menu
for yourself and Mr. Borden.

Mm-hmm.

♪ Nice try ♪

♪ Now get out the way ♪

♪ Good job ♪

♪ Just take a f*cking hint ♪

♪ I said I'll see ya ♪

♪ Wouldn't wanna be ya ♪

♪ Wouldn't wanna be ya
Ee-ya-ee-ya-ee-ya-ee-ya-ee-ya... ♪


[panting]

Oh, Sarah!

[panting gasps]

♪ You're in our way ♪

- ♪ Get lost forever ♪
- [song ends]

Who's Sarah, sir?

Your first wife?

Don't say her name, please.

Well...

I have something to tell you.

I am in a family way.

I'm...

heavy with your seed, sir.

I see.

Thought you were making use
of prophylaxis.

[chuckles] Well... indeed I am, sir.

But it is more an art than a science.

And you do mount me
with some frequency, Mr. Borden.

Do you not have
something to say about this?

I suppose I don't.

Allow me, then.

I will have your b*stard

unless you pay me.

And if you do so, I will get rid of it.

I will be discreet.

I won't miss a day of work.

And we can go back to doing what we do.

And if I don't allow myself
to be extorted?

Then I will have to ask Mrs. Borden
what she will make of this dilemma.

I'll let you think about it.

Good day.

[door opens]

[door shuts]

[Lizzie] When will it stop?

[exhales deeply]

The fevers have never come
two months in a row.

May I...

take a look?

May I examine you... down there?

To see if something's wrong?

Lay on your back.

[soft music playing]

I need you to open your legs for me.

Just...

It's your hymen.

It's imperforated.

[sighs]

It's covering everything.

Your kitty's strong.

How do I stop the pain? I have to tear it?

You can have a doctor make an incision
in the membrane.

Or something else...

like it.

I have to have a husband to do that.

No.

[quick expectant music plays]

Good day, sir.
Has a parcel arrived for me?

[postman] Nothing for Mr. Borden today.

No, for me. Bridget Sullivan.

[postman] Hmm.

I don't know if I can do this.

Let's try it.

Doctors use it.

And it wasn't cheap.

It's called a Chattanooga.

Its member goes inside you.

I just... put it into gear.

And then it should go like the clappers.

[steam hissing]

[clicking]

- [whirring]
- [grinding]

[squeaking]

[laughing]

[whooshing]

- [steam hisses]
- [contraption slows to a stop]

- [both laugh]
- No, maybe not.

Maybe we try something different.

[chuckles]

Hm.

[bright music playing]

[music settles and fades slowly]

[Mrs. Borden] Ooh!

And what is this?

It's bouillabaisse, Madame.

It's a French soup from Marseille.

I made it
with the leftovers of the crayfish.

It's part of the new summer menu
I made for yourself and Mr. Borden.

[light classical music playing]

- Where have you been, Emma?
- [Mrs. Borden] Don't pry, Lizzie.

Where she's been
is out of her father's hair.

Which is more than can be said for you.

Where she's been is out finding a husband.

- Isn't that right, Emma?
- Mm-hmm.

You have a suitor?

I do.

- Who?
- I said don't pry.

It's a warm body.
That's all you need to know.

It's Bard Wainright.

[Mr. Borden] Hmm. Good family.

[Emma] Mmm.

It's delicious, Maggie.

Oh, Mr. Borden, I almost forgot.

We must look for a new house painter.

I fired that swarthy, no-good Portuguese.

Why?

Because it's May, Mr. Borden.

I was opening up the house,

every window and door,
to let the vapors out.


And then I noticed my earbobs missing.

Where are my earbobs?

That Portugee had to have snuck in
and pocketed them and then run off.


And what would Tiago want
with your earbobs?

Why, to sell them, of course.

To pay for his... opium or whatnot.

Oh, and Maggie...

lazing around the house all day
is doing no good

for Mr. Borden's youngest here.

Tomorrow, you will take Lizzie into town.

I know,

to be seen alongside her is a burden,
but that is why we pay you.

[Mr. Borden] Maggie.

Perhaps while you're at it, you might

pick up my newest axe
from the post office.

That's a good girl.

[slurping]

[exhales quickly]

[sobbing softly]

[sniffs, sighs]

[music fades slowly]

Are you all right? You look tired.

Yes, I'm tired.

It'll be... be fine in one or two days.

[postman] Yeah, that's quite an axe.

More for felling trees than woodworking,
I'd have thought.

Can I take it just like that?

I suppose so.

Why are we stopped?

The matinée. I got us tickets.

[soft laugh]

[laughs]

Après vous.

- [light music playing]
- [indistinct chattering]

[audience clapping]

[man] ...waking looks upon,
be it on lion, bear, or wolf, or bull,

on meddling monkey, or on busy ape.

She shall pursue it with the soul of love.

And ere I take this charm
from off her sight.

As I can take it with another...

Teeth. Boy! Teeth! Now!

[man] ...render up her page to me!

How canst thou thus for shame, Titania,

glance at my credit with Hippolyta,
knowing I know thy love to Theseus?

Didst thou not lead him
through the glimmering night

from Perigenia, whom he ravished,

and make him
with fair Aegle break his faith,

with Ariadne and Antiopa?

These are the forgeries of jealousy.

And never, since middle summer's spring,

met we on hill, in dale, forest, or mead,

by paved fountain or rushy brook or...

Who is she?

Her name is Nance O'Neil.

They say
she's the American Sarah Bernhardt.

...our ringlets to the whistling wind.

Oh, she's enchanting!

She's not very good.

[applause]

[indistinct chattering]

Ah, my audience! Thank you.
Thank you, beautiful souls.

Kind souls, thank you. Thank you.

- Here.
- Please.

[sighs]

There.

Now, don't just sock that in a drawer.

That autograph is worth something.

Thank you, my dears, my dear audience.

Miss O'Neil, you were extraordinary.

- And so were you.
- No.

Beautiful audience.

I see every one of you out there.

Thank you.

Yes. Oh, you don't have a pen, dear.

- Oh.
- Can I borrow this?

Thank you so much.

- Oh.
- Yes.

Miss O'Neil,

you were extraordinary.

Just marvelous.

- Thank you.
- Look at that hair.

Doesn't quite work, does it?

But for the effort?

[claps] Brava.

This is going to sound like
a terrible opinion to some,

but I really hate the color purple.

Really?

Why is that?

It is the shade of a boil
on an Italian beggar.

The shade of a cancer
that needs to be cut out,

eliminated at once to save the patient.

Anyway, I hate it, the color purple,
and I always will. Thank you.

- Miss O'Neil...
- Lizzie.

You're staying in Fall River
for the next few weeks, aren't you?

Yes.

Then off to Poughkeepsie.

Aha.

I wondered if you might like
to come to dinner.

You're probably staying
at one of those dreadful boarding houses,

And I wondered if you might like
a home-cooked meal.

Maggie is a wonderful cook.

We're the Borden House,
just down 2nd Street.

Sounds splendid.

I'll have Beef Wellington.

Rare, but not blue.

Pink in the center, and cool.

Also, and this is important,

the various side dishes.

Peas, for instance, and carrots, say.

These mustn't be allowed to touch.

And if they do, I become nauseous
and lose my appetite entirely,

and as my body is my instrument,

the instrument becomes malnourished.

[Lizzie] Yes, yes.

See you then.

See you then.

Nice axe.

We should have written that down.

[thunder rumbling]

[Maggie groans]

Ow.

[Maggie] Mm.

Yes?

Yes?

[door creaks]

Dear God. You look awful.

I... I thought you might read to me.

Come.

[bed creaking]

Where were we?

Hmm.

"A mob pressed a local magistrate
to question the countess

about the peasant girls who disappeared."

[pounding on door]

{\an8}[woman in Hungarian]

[door creaking]

[unsettling music rises]

[door thuds]

[Maggie in English] But the countess
blamed her handmaidens for the murders.


{\an8}[in Hungarian]

[low murmuring]

[overlapping shouts]

{\an8}[Countess]

[shouting continues]

[unsettling music swells]

[women wailing]

[Maggie in English]
Ilona had her fingers torn off.

[screaming]

[indistinct shouts]

Doryotta was burned alive.

[screaming]

And because the mob
pitied the youngest, Katarina,


she was simply beheaded.

{\an8}[in Hungarian]

{\an8}[Maggie in English] And just like that,
the countess had discovered a new hobby.


[Maggie groans]

I'm sorry, I have to...

Mmm... It's happening.

What's wrong?

It's nothing. It's just...

Oof...

[groans, inhales sharply]

[grunts] I'm... I'm passing a fetus.

- [grunts]
- [liquid splashing]

What can I do?

Um, put two drops of the...

You see the... the bottles?

Can you fill this glass with two drops
of the first one into the glass?

Yes.

And then two...
three spoons of the second one.

And then you fill it to the brim
with the... with the big...

[straining]

Mmm...

It's all right, it's fine.

Thank you.

It stops the infection.

Mmm.

Thank you. [inhales deeply]

[sighs]

There's something I...

There's something I have to tell you.

What? Anything.

[light string music builds slowly]

This blood is your blood.

It's your father.

That's why he has me working in the...

in his workshop.

So he can be alone with me.

So he has me to himself.

No, no. That can't be true.

- Yes.
- No.

- You don't have to stay.
- I want to stay.

- No, you don't have to stay.
- I'll stay. I want to stay.

- [Maggie sighs softly]
- [music fades]

{\an8}[birds chirping]

Miss Borden, would you do me the honor of...

of being my wife?

Oh, Bard!

[exhales shakily]

Emma, Emma!

Hey, my darling.

I don't understand.

Does your sister live here?

I've been here a month,
and I hardly ever see her.

[Bard] My darling.

Emma comes and goes with the wind.

[Bard] Emma.

Everything a girl could want
just falls into her lap.

[Bard] My darling.

- My darling.
- Mm.

I'm here.

Oh.

Oh, Bard.

Oh.

Of course I'll marry you.

[laughing] Of course.

[laughing]

[Emma] I'm not marrying him.

Sure, Bard is handsome

and very well-endowed... [chuckles]

And rich enough, I suppose.

So I'll string him along
for a few months and then break it off.

Just like the last two.

Why?

Getting hog-tied to one man
for the rest of your life, Lizzie,

that sounds fun to you?

That same a*s breath,
that same ball bag slapping at your madge

until death comes
to relieve you of the tedium.

I'm telling you, that is not for me.

And I'm not letting them
at Father's money anyway.

That's what they're really after.

How much is Father worth?

[light scoff]

Do you really not know?

I suppose we're quite well off
with the servants,

and cholera outbreaks
are keeping the coffin business brisk--

$300,000.

What?

[Mrs. Borden] What are you
talking about down there?

Nothing, Mrs. Borden.

Listen to you.

You so clearly love having a tormentor.

That's why Father doesn't respect you.

That's why... you won't get anything.

What do you mean?

When they die.

Father knows how
feeble-minded you are. [chuckles]

You get 5%, I get the rest.

[Emma sighs]

[Lizzie] I don't understand.
It's so cruel.




That's still a sh*t barge of money.

That's $15,000.
With that, you can buy your own house.

You can... you can buy a plot of land

and still have enough money to
not lift a finger the rest of your life.

That isn't what I mean.

I know.

But money...

is freedom.

And you can pick cherries all you want,
and you can tend to your dovecote,

and you can be free,

so free that...

no one can tell you anything.

[doves cooing]

[whispering] Anything.

[breathing deeply]

You know, at 11 weeks,
baby doves stop looking so strange.

They can open their eyes.

They stop looking like little demons.

[wings flapping]

[cooing intensifies]

What did you do that for?

Because I felt like it.

I should be saving my kiss for my beau.

Maybe I should be your beau.

[gentle music plays]

[humming a tune]

Maggie, look at all the motes.

They're like little angels.

They're like little fairies
watching over us, protecting us.

[Maggie] Fairies.

Your fairies are my life's chore.

[Lizzie laughs]

They land on every surface that I dust off
so that I have to dust it all over again.

[bird singing]

Hello.

Hello.

I can't believe it's May.

Paris is so beautiful in May.

One day I'll take you.

And we'll have champagne and oysters.

Except we couldn't have oysters in May.

- Why?
- [music fades]

- [pensive music plays]
- In May, sea gets warmer, air gets hot.

And 1st May,
Fall River flushes the sewers.

Now sewage flows right out
over her oyster shoals.

And oysters are filter feeders, you know,

so summers they get a bacillus in them.

They sit out just a few minutes in the sun
and they start to stink.

Eat one. It could k*ll you.

[music ends]

Let's poison them.

What?

Yeah. With the oysters.

Poison them?

Yes.

I mean, we wouldn't really.

They would poison themselves.

We would just give them what they want.

No.

You should be ashamed
for even saying that.

Just think of it.

No.

- [cooing]
- [splashing]

- [flapping]
- [sloshing]

- [cooing]
- [flapping]

[sighs]

- [distant cooing]
- [breathing heavily]

[unsettling music builds]

[flapping and cooing grows louder]

[loud cooing]

- [shrill notes play]
- [breathing heavily]

[huffs]

[flapping and cooing intensifies]

[shrill music builds to crescendo]

[shrill note holds steady]

[Mrs. Borden grunting]

- [gasping]
- [axe thudding]

[shrill music intensifies]

[grunts harshly]

- [grunts]
- What are you doing?

I'm not k*lling these birds, Lizzie.

You are.

I told you I couldn't stand the cooing.

The noise... the noise
has driven me to the brink!

But you are thick!

And willful!

So I did what you made me do.

[gasps] No!

[shouting] No, no!

No!

Shut your mouth
or I'll fill it with bird sh*t.

[music turns somber]

I have relieved you of that useless hobby

that nearly condemned you
to the fate of a hideous old maid.

You should thank me.

I have removed that distraction.

Now you can concentrate on a new hobby.

[grunts]

Finding a man
and leaving this f*cking house!

[music stops]

[Lizzie sobs softly]

[squelching]

[door opens]

[door shuts]

[Lizzie sobbing]

[somber music playing]

[soft cooing]

[Lizzie] Father.

How can I help?

[gasping, breathing shakily]

[shouts] Aren't you curious?

I'm covered in blood and feathers.

All right.

What happened?

Father, she m*rder*d my doves.

She m*rder*d them.

With no pretext, no provocation.

I need you to do something.

For once in your life,
show me that you care about me.

I am your daughter.

You stand by and you watch
as she treats me as she does,

and you do nothing.

You do nothing.

[music stops]

Nothing.

That's what I... do, is it?

[tense music rises slowly]

You have no idea
what it feels like to be me.

You do nothing to help me.

No one does.

I have no... son.

I have no... respite from the droning
of shrill female voices,

on and on and on and on

in a house that I... toil for night and day.

And all that I ask, all that I ask

is that you don't... bring me your troubles!

[music intensifies]

[shouts] Birds!

[yelling] Birds?

I don't give a Christ's dead c*ck

about your birds.

I don't give a single,
solitary, airborne f*ck!

[music recedes]

[panting]

Is that clear?

Or

are you... too thick to understand?

[music turns solemn]

[breathing shakily]

I understand.

[Mr. Borden sighs]

Good.

[sweeping classical music plays]

[clanging]

[door opens]

- [music stops]
- We're gonna k*ll them.

Yeah.

["Cuntology 101" by Lambrini Girls plays]

[gasps] Mr. Borden, look!
A new menu for summer.

[laughs]

Hm.

♪ Getting used to saying no is cunty
Getting out of your comfort zone ♪


♪ Learning how to let go is cunty
Having c*m on my shirt is cunty ♪


♪ Setting boundaries is cunty
Respecting others is cunty too ♪


♪ Putting yourself first is cunty
Learning to love yourself is cunty ♪


♪ C-U-N-T ♪

♪ I'm gonna do what's best for me
I'm cunty ♪


♪ That's cunty
C-U-N-T ♪


♪ I'll prioritize my own needs
I'm cunty ♪


♪ That's cunty, cunty, cunty
Wow ♪


[up-tempo instrumental continues]

Ugh.

Rosemary.

Ginger.

And cardamom.

It's hard to find, but...

it'll hide the smell.

Voilà.

♪ Five, six, seven, eight ♪

♪ You can't take that away
I'm cunty ♪


Ugh!

♪ It's Cuntology 101, b*tch ♪

Do you really think it'll work?

Oh, yeah.

Do you really think it'll k*ll them?

- [coughs]
- Yeah.

They call it vibriosis.

First they vomit, and they vomit blood.

Then they have blood
coming out of their a*s,

then out of their eyes,
out of every orifice.

It's a gruesome way to die,
but they deserve it.

- [rock song fades]
- [light classical music playing]

I thought Emma might sup with us tonight.

Why would you think that?

She's betrothed now.

She has no need to suck herself swollen
off her father's largesse

like some at the table do.

[Mr. Borden] Mmm.
I'd like to commend you, Mother.

[Mrs. Borden] For what?

Why, for the eradication of those doves.

You know how I loathe the feces of fowl.

Oh! Took you long enough.

Or have I forgotten how to read a clock?

I'm very sorry, Madame.

Wh-- What is that? Soup?

[Maggie] Yes, Madame.

Hm. Smells delightful.

Although I'm almost past hunger.
You kept us waiting far too long.

[Maggie] Shall I serve you first,
then, Madame? Or Mr. Borden?

No, me. Me first.

Mmm.

[Mr. Borden sighs]

[music ends]

[sipping]

[Mr. Borden clears throat]

Bless us, O Lord, in these thy gifts,

which we are... about to receive
from thy bounty

through... Christ our Lord. Amen.

[Mrs. Borden] Mm.

Amen.

[Mrs. Borden] Mm!

Well, that does smell good.

[Mr. Borden] Mm.

[door creaking]

[sniffs]

- [Mr. Borden] Mm.
- Hmm.

It's... delicious.

[Mrs. Borden] Mm!

Mmm...

Oh, it's tasty.

Mmm!

- [Mrs. Borden] Mm!
- Mm.

I was hungry.

- [chuckles]
- [clock striking]

[slurping]

That's cardamom.

[clock strikes]

- [Mrs. Borden] Is it?
- Mm.

Delicious.

I might go back for seconds.

[clock strikes]

[slurping]

[clock strikes speed up]

Mm.

- [chuckles]
- [Mr. Borden exclaims]

[discordant notes playing]

[Mrs. Borden] Mmm-mm!

[slurping gently]

[discordant notes]

[Mrs. Borden] Ooh! I've got a big one.

[Lizzie] Mm.

This Maggie is a much better cook
than the last Maggie.

And without that hunch in her back.

She looked like a... little gnome.

[Mr. Borden chuckles]

[giggles]

[Mr. Borden laughs]

I do love it when you're mirthful, Mother.

[both laughing]

- [stomach growls]
- [Mr. Borden coughs]

[giggles]

[Mr. Borden chuckles]

[chuckles] Mm...

[stomach growling]

[Mr. Borden] Hm.

[Mrs. Borden] Mm.

- [Mr. Borden] What?
- [stomach grumbling]

Just that... last bite.

- [gurgling]
- [grunts] Strange taste to it.

- [rumbling]
- [clears throat]

[Mrs. Borden] Is it... um...

Mine is delicious.

- Mm-hm.
- [Mr. Borden] Hm.

[gurgling]

[Mrs. Borden gasps]

I wonder if possibly those oyst--

[retching]

- [Mrs. Borden panting]
- Oh.

[classical music builds slowly]

Excuse... excuse me one... one second.

[gurgling]

[retching]

[straining]

[Mrs. Borden] Maggie!

[door creaking]

Maggie!

[rousing classical music playing]

[gasping, panting]

Make it stop.

Right away, Madame.

[retching, coughing]

[gagging, coughs]

It's nothing, it's just...

just a spot of blood.

I am purged.

It is... [retching] ...over.

[moaning]

No.

No.

[sighs]

[gurgling]

It's the... cardamom.

- [groans]
- [deep gurgling]

[heavy grumbling]

[prolonged squelching]

[shuddering moan]

[straining]

[thudding]

[weak groan]

- [Mr. Borden grunts]
- [splashy gushing]

- [Mrs. Borden retches]
- [damp splattering]

[wet flatulence]

- [Mr. Borden coughs]
- [prolonged sloshing]

[weak moan]

- [thud]
- [retching]

[soggy slushing]

[flatulent squelching]

[soppy rippling]

[thudding]

[music diminishes]

I'll fetch the doctor.

[music amplifies]

[music ends]

They are still resting.

But the vomiting is continuous.

I fear they may not make it
through the night.

Mrs. Borden mentioned

oysters?

Oh. Yes.

Yes, I had one.

And it... I feel fine.

So does Maggie.

[doctor] Hm.

That is quite the puzzle.

Quite dangerous,
you know, to eat oysters in May.

A good fishmonger
would have told you that.

[door opens]

[creaking]

[ominous music playing]

I'll finish the cleaning.
You... you go take a bath.

- [music ends]
- [birds chirping]

[owl hooting]

[church bells tolling]

[laughing]

[Maggie humming a tune]

Did they stir in the night?

No.

[Mrs. Borden] Maggie?

[slow tense music playing]

Maggie!

What?

They must have vomited it out.

They purged it.

Maggie!

Yes, Mrs. Borden?

Good morning, Lizzie.

- You do know that's your name, don't you?
- [Mr. Borden] Hm.

I called for Maggie.

Maggie?

I'd like to fire you.

Or at least have you strung up
in a tree outside the magistrate

for that bilious concoction
that made Mr. Borden and myself so ill.

I tell you,
sometimes a good purge like that

is just what the doctor ordered.

I feel good as new this morning.

Restored.

Fix us johnnycakes and coffee, Maggie.

You should have
thought of as much already.

Nothing for me.

I think I'll just take the air.

[unsettling music plays]

[door creaks open]

[music turns somber]

They still don't suspect anything.

We could try a different poison.

No, I know how we're gonna k*ll them.

[staccato piano notes playing]

[slow somber piano melody plays]