Bear Lake Murders, The (2025)

[bunniefuu]

You look breathtaking

in that one, Sarah.

So full of life.

Who's behind the camera?

A boyfriend?

No.

Oh, my God.

Please let me go.

A sister, a mom, and dad.

But no pictures

of any boyfriend or husband.

You live alone.

In the middle of nowhere.

This is your sanctuary,

isn't it?

Huh.

But what are you running from?

That was a rhetorical question.

Did he hurt you?

No.

You left him.

You always leave them.

Don't you?

Why?

Why? Why? Why?

Oh.

Don't worry about that.

We'll get to know each other

much more

before you'll have

to worry about that.

Now, let's talk a bit

about your abandonment issues.

And why they make you

reject the men

who go out of their way

to make you happy.

- What do you want?

- Drop the knife, Caden.

Detective Ally Foster.

I said drop the knife.

It's over.

I wondered how long it would

take you to find me.

- Three years.

- No.

Correction.

You were chasing a serial

k*ller for three years.

You haven't been

chasing me that long.

What made you figure it out?

I told them it was someone

who knew the system.

Someone who knew

how we profiled K*llers.

Someone who taught you people

how to do that.

But what led you to me?

Murderers always

make mistakes.

You taught me that.

What makes you think mistakes

were made, Ally?

You should know this

more than anybody else.

As time goes by,

most want to get caught.

They practically dare you

to find them.

Well, that's the rush.

The unhinged element

in their psyche

that makes it impossible

for them to connect to reality.

Three years of your life.

Cost you everything, didn't it?

We don't have time

for monologues, Caden.

No, you're not gonna sh**t me.

If you sh**t me,

you won't find out the reasons.

You won't know the whys.

Or the hows.

Like I said,

we don't have time.

So...

They finally believe you, Ally.

I'm so happy for you.

And I look forward

to working with you again.

I have so, so much to teach you.

- Forced leave?

- Ally.

I just closed

the biggest case

this department has ever had.

Full prosecution.

And you're benching me?

Ally, sit, please.

You look exhausted.

There's nothing wrong with

a little rest and relaxation.

I'd k*ll for that order myself.

- Take advantage of it.

- Captain, I wanna work.

You've had me off cases ever

since Caden Hodge, which is--

I know. I know. Look...

I need you to cut me

some slack here.

I've had the department

psychologist

all over my back about you,

saying that you're burnt out

ever since

this Caden Hodge thing.

Your psych eval did not go well.

They're misreading me.

They're saying I'm agitated

or... whatever.

It's 'cause I wanna work.

- It's the work that'll keep me--

- Keep you what?

Sane?

Busy.

- Distracted.

- Ally, there's more to life

than this case.

I need something

to help me move on.

It's not a request, Ally.

It's a department order.

Caden Hodge is found guilty

and he'll be sentenced for

the rest of his life in prison.

You did it.

I need you to put in

some effort here.

Get out of the city.

Now, what about that cabin

from your hometown,

up in the mountains?

Bear Lake, yeah.

But I haven't been there

in years.

Not since Dad died.

Show me, show them,

that you can get away

for a couple weeks.

A couple of weeks?

- Captain!

- And then when you get back,

you tell the psychologist

about sitting by the lake,

dipping your toes in the water,

and just how good

it was for you.

Then you're back in the game.

You could've emailed me this.

Yeah, well,

your captain just wanted

to see with his own two eyes

how you were doing.

Well, uh, 9 a.m.

if the traffic out of

the city isn't too bad.

Yeah.

Um, hey, Lisa, can you just

not mention it to anyone?

Yeah, I don't want people

knowing that I'm coming back

into town.

All right, okay.

Thanks for taking care

of everything.

Okay, bye.

Okay.

Hey, what's up, Lisa?

Hello, Ally.

Caden?

How did...

Well, I've got a good lawyer.

He demanded I be able

to call a loved one

before my transfer

to the prison tonight.

A loved one?

I heard you're on leave.

How did you know that?

Like I said,

I have a good lawyer.

I just wanted to say goodbye.

And thank you.

It was a wonderful game.

It wasn't a game.

Why are you really calling me?

What are you up to?

I gotta go.

I'll see you soon.

Come live all

your vacation dreams

through my eyes

at Sienna's Travel Vibes.

Hello.

Yeah.

Uh, I'll be here

for a couple days,

but I'll make it seem like

it was a couple weeks.

That's what gets them.

I go on the vacations

and they do their best

to live up to them if they go.

All right, yeah.

I'll call you

when I'm at the airport.

Okay. Bye.

Hi, everyone!

I'm about to start

my next adventure.

This time, I'm headed

to the mountains,

to one of the hottest

mountain lake

Bear Lake.

It's turned from

a favorite local summer spot

to a budding national hotspot.

It's known for amazing hiking,

rock climbing, water sports,

boating, and lakeside partying.

A little bit everything

for everyone.

We'll see you when I get there.

Chief here.

Okay.

Well then,

tell those college kids

they can't camp out

on some local's

beachfront property.

I don't care if they wanna

see your supervisor, Brody.

I did lake shift last night.

I'm supposed to be

having a late start.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Okay, I'll be there

in 15 minutes.

It's gonna be one

of those days.

Hey, you won't believe this.

Look.

It's official Bear Lake

business, I promise.

I'm so glad to have you

back for summer break.

Sienna Hartley.

I'm obsessed

with her travel reels.

Everyone is.

Bear Lake.

It's turned from

a favorite local--

Why am I watching this?

She's coming to Bear Lake.

Can you believe it?

She goes to the best places.

She vacations and shares

all of the best tips.

Places to stay, things to do.

The way she shoots, edits,

and posts them,

it's like you're

on the vacation with her.

God, I'd do anything

to meet her.

To have her life.

Your life's that bad, is it?

I wanna do what she does.

See the world.

If I came back here

after I graduate,

I just can't.

I love you and I love Bear Lake.

But...

If you're not here,

who's gonna take care of me

during those crazy

tourist months?

You're all grown up,

big brother.

- It's time to let you fly.

- Hmm.

And hey,

you're chief of police now.

Don't.

Women love a man in a uniform.

You'll be fine.

Okay. I'm gonna go downtown.

- See if I can find her.

- You want a ride?

No, I'm okay.

Gives me time to check out

the early bird tourist guys.

If their eyes linger too long,

I'm locking 'em up.

I can handle myself.

Hey, and you're finishing

college, Rebecca.

Don't let that Sienna Hartley

girl give you any ideas.

Sienna Hartley's

a made-up name.

Well, good morning, Pat.

Did the bakery deliver

those donuts yet?

- Sure did.

- The sprinkle ones, too?

- Of course.

- Oh no, you did not.

- Did too.

- You, oh.

Wait, Ally?

Ally Foster.

It's... You recognize me?

It's Brody.

Brody Doyle.

Oh, right. Yeah.

- Hi.

- Hey.

You know it's...

Everybody here

is talking about you

'cause of Caden Hodge.

Uh? That's uh...

That's uh, that's nice.

You're uh,

you're a deputy, hey?

Oh, yeah. Yeah, it's been

a few years now, yeah.

You know, and speaking

of which, you know,

I imagine Chief would love

to know you're back in town.

Oh, I won't be back

for very long.

Well, you know,

he's just doing his rounds.

You can just...

I'm sure he'd like...

Hey, can you turn that up,

please?

We have breaking news

tonight.

The late night transfer

from the city jail

to the state prison

ran off the mountain highway

in the middle of the night,

plummeting nearly 100 feet

onto the shores of a river.

Two prison guards, a driver,

and four prisoners

are believed to have perished,

although, two of the bodies

have yet to be found,

including that of

serial k*ller, Caden Hodge.

Hodge was on route to serve

consecutive life sentences

for 20 grisly murders.

That's a heck of a way to go.

I knew it was you

the whole time, dear.

Wanted to respect your privacy.

You did the world a service

taking him off the streets.

- You should be proud.

- Thank you.

Hey, Brody, can you um,

not let anyone know

that I'm here for now?

It's good to see you.

Miles.

Damn!

Sorry, didn't mean

to scare you.

Well, you did.

If I had my g*n,

I would've shot you.

That's fair enough. Probably

should've said something.

I was just making

my way back to my cabin.

Yeah, around the lake.

Yeah, I remember.

Taking the long way home?

- It's been a while.

- Yeah.

- You're back.

- So are you.

No, I mean from the military.

Yeah.

Um... served for a while.

Was discharged.

Honorably discharged.

Figured it was time

to come home.

- Your parents?

- Retired.

Couldn't handle

the winters anymore.

They live in Arizona.

So, I bought the cabin

off of them

and took over

their logging company.

Well...

Yeah, I gotta get back

to the cabin.

- I uh, I got a work call.

- Oh, yeah. Yeah.

I didn't want to impose.

I just wanted

to make sure there wasn't

some tourist wandering

your property.

Yeah.

Seems to be a lot

of them these days.

It's crazy.

It's not even

tourist season yet

and it's like

they've taken over the town.

Listen, uh...

I'm going into town

to get some coffee.

Do you wanna...

I'd love to,

but I got the uh...

- Work call.

- Yeah.

Raincheck, though.

Right. That'd be great.

Um, it was good to see you.

Yeah, see ya.

Ally, I tried calling

and texting you.

I didn't hear 'til

first thing this morning.

They were transferring

Caden Hodge

in the middle of the night

for security reasons.

Yeah, I didn't have

any reception up to Bear Lake.

- They still haven't found him?

- No.

Just the other missing

prisoner's body

halfway down the river.

Listen, I know

what you're thinking.

You don't know him

like I do, Captain.

No one could have

survived that crash.

He could have.

He probably caused

the whole thing.

All right, believe me, Ally,

even if he did survive,

he'd be stupid to try

and come after you.

And even if he did,

Bear Lake is the last place

he'd be looking for you.

When he called, he knew

I was going on leave, Captain.

From jail he knew.

Wouldn't take much for him

to guess where I was going.

Bear Lake is 40 miles

from the crash site,

just over the pass.

- Okay.

I'll contact you the moment

I have any updates.

But Ally, he's gone.

He's gone, Ally.

- Um, hi.

- Hi.

Does it normally take

this long to make a coffee?

Sorry. It's an older machine,

but it makes the flavor

so much better.

It's fine.

Take your time.

Don't expect

the best review, though.

She's right, you know.

Excuse me?

This is the best coffee

in the country.

And trust me, I've been around.

It's worth the extra

120 seconds

of your apparent precious time.

Guess Bear Lake's reputation

for kindness was overrated.

God.

Wanna know what I think

is overrated?

You tourists.

You come into this town,

you treat everybody

like your servant.

They work hard for you.

You should appreciate that.

So rude.

You know what? I changed

my mind. I'll take it to go.

Oh, my God!

Oh! What is it with this place?

Oh, I'm sorry.

I didn't see you there.

- Obviously you didn't see me.

- Look, I know the waitress.

I can get you

a new coffee right away.

It's just, I have to say,

I am a big fan.

I watch all of your reels,

like multiple times.

I want to do what you do.

I mean, I don't think

I could do it

as well as you but--

- No, you couldn't.

What?

Look, it's not

as easy as it looks, okay?

You people just

watch the reels

and you think

it's all simple and--

No, no, I know you put

a lot into it.

That's what I love.

Just stick to whatever

it is you do around here.

God!

Hey there, Becca.

Hey, Brody.

I uh, kinda overheard

all that.

Hmm.

Yeah, my dad always said

never to meet your heroes.

'Cause they'll always

let you down. Yeah.

Told me the same thing, yeah.

I hear she's headed up

to the point.

You follow her, too?

Well, yeah, saw that you

liked her and uh, it's...

Oh. You checkin'

my likes, huh?

Well, you know,

you back for the summer? Yeah?

Well, okay, then um,

what're you up to today?

I was actually thinking

about getting my hike in.

Oh. Okay, well,

I mean, I'm headed up

to the campgrounds anyways.

I could... Maybe we could go

for a quick coffee?

Then I could drive you there.

I'll take you to the north side.

It's on my way

and I imagine you don't wanna

go to the point after.

- No.

Yeah.

I'll stay as far away

from her as possible.

Trust me.

Sounds good.

Okay well, after you.

Yeah.

Oh, the weather here

is just perfect, too!

It cannot get any better.

Yep, she's headed up

to the point.

You know what?

You could do such

a better job at that than her.

You think?

Yeah. Yeah, of course.

I mean, look at her.

I mean, she's fake.

And you, you're... you're real

and you're relatable.

And you're a thousand

times prettier.

Not that that matters,

or anything, but...

I'm not supposed

to tell you this.

Ally's back.

- What?

- Mm-hmm.

Does Roy know?

Well no, he was just

doing his rounds.

And she told me

not to tell anybody.

But I kinda got the sense that

she only really meant for him.

Hmm.

Interesting.

Wanna go?

How come you never

asked me out?

I didn't know

you wanted me to.

I didn't know either.

Well, it was your dad.

You know, just...

I don't think he really

liked me that much.

Sure, he did.

Well, okay, then maybe

the thought of,

you know, anybody asking you out

bothered him.

But look, sorry, I didn't mean

to bring him up, it's...

No, it's okay.

Maybe on your next night off,

we can go out?

So, are you sure you wanna be

dropped off all the way up here?

Yeah, I wanna enjoy the view

for a bit and then hike down.

You aren't going

to the point, are you?

- No.

- No?

Besides, she's not a local.

It'll take her hours

to get up here.

Mm-hmm.

I'll hike

to the other overlook.

Okay, well, you be careful.

Yeah, okay.

Yeah.

Hey! Your girl has been

filming this beautiful place

too much apparently, because

my battery is about to die.

But I am bound and determined

to get through this hike,

to what's supposed to be

the scenic overlook

of Bear Lake.

It's been an interesting

trip so far.

We'll see you in a bit.

All right,

that was a legit hike.

A couple hours,

but it was worth it.

Check this out.

As you can see, your girl lives

for livin' on the edge.

Oh, looks like

the mountain air

has sucked up all my battery

for this hike.

I will hit you up tonight

for the nightlife of Bear Lake,

if there is any.

We'll see you soon!

All right,

here you are, Chief.

I finally got these

out of storage for you, here.

Thank you, Brody.

My dad was always resistant

to computers

and I'm paying the price for it.

Yeah, well,

he was old-fashioned, so.

But um, why did you want

all these old incident

reports anyways?

I gotta get them scanned

and put in the new system.

Local deaths have been

on the rise in past years.

Last year, Dad's last,

we got lucky.

But before that.

Yeah well, you know,

it's just, it's tourists.

It's like they're multiplying

out there.

Yeah, they're coming earlier

and earlier now, too.

I've never seen so many before

the summer even starts.

Dad always said we needed

more deputies year-round.

Anyway, few weeks,

we'll get our seasonals,

and hopefully, we won't be

so overloaded.

Let's just hope those tourists

don't do anything stupid

before then.

Oh, hey, uh,

thanks for skipping out

on your annual hunting trip

with your dad and brothers,

by the way.

- I really appreciate that.

- Oh, yeah, yeah. It's nothing.

I mean,

around this time of year,

they were throwing snakes

in my tent,

and then, shaving my head

in the middle of the night.

So, yeah, trust me,

I'm not missing much.

- Older brothers will do that.

- Hmm.

It was an interesting haircut

to start the summer off with.

I'll tell ya that.

Well, alrighty.

I'm gonna go get

some food at the diner.

- Do you want anything?

- No.

Oh, Chief.

Chief, Chief, Chief, listen,

I'm not supposed

to tell you this, but um...

Caden!

Told you I'd see you again.

Welcome home, Ally.

You expecting someone else?

Uh, yeah.

I wasn't expecting you.

Come on in.

Brody never could

keep a secret.

Can't believe he's a deputy.

He was always so skittish.

Yeah, he's not one

to command authority.

He drove my dad crazy.

But he's learning.

And you, chief.

I'm no famous detective.

Heard about

the prison transfer.

Yeah, wasn't much

of a transfer, was it?

Explains my warm welcoming.

Hmm.

You don't think that he's...

That's the one thing

about him.

If you don't expect

the unexpected,

you're always two steps

behind him instead of one.

Listen, I uh...

I should've been there for you

when your parents--

Oh no, it's okay.

No, it's not.

You were there for me

when Dad died.

You were amazing, Roy.

And I loved them and I should've

been there for you.

I'm sorry.

I just got so caught up

in this investigation.

No, you're doing

important work.

Yeah, but...

I don't know.

I could've reached out, too.

Just didn't wanna use it

as some excuse

to get you to come back.

I did try calling

a few years back,

but your number

was disconnected.

Yeah, the department

gives us phones,

so I just thought

it was silly to have two.

And yeah, maybe I used it

as an excuse to cut the cord.

I couldn't be here anymore.

It's strange.

When I lost them is when I knew

I could never leave.

We all grieve

in different ways, I guess.

Saw Miles earlier today.

- Yeah?

- Yeah, he's uh, he's different.

Mm-hmm, always was.

No, he's even more so now.

It's like he's empty inside.

Do you talk to him ever?

It's hard not to run into

each other in a place like this.

Yeah, but do you talk to him?

Not much.

Things haven't been

the same since...

Us.

Mm-hmm.

- He was your best friend.

- Yeah, well,

best friends don't try and steal

your girlfriend, for two.

I know I said I'm sorry

like a million times,

but it just doesn't

feel like enough.

I just couldn't stay, Roy.

And I couldn't get you

to come with me.

Miles was just someone

I could talk to about it.

I think he saw an opportunity

and he tried to take it.

He always liked you, Ally.

And I can't blame the guy.

Nothing ever happened.

31 for two.

Anyhoo, it was

a long time ago.

The past is in the past.

You lead.

Uh, Chief, you there?

Yeah, Brody, what's up?

I'm gonna need you to come up

to the base of the point.

What are you doing up there?

Someone found a body.

I'll be right there.

I jinxed us.

Told Brody that I hope we'd go

another year without...

I know that look.

City jurisdiction extends

into the mountains.

Seasonal deputies don't get

here for a few weeks.

I sure as hell

could use the help.

Brody?

I know her.

You do?

I know of her.

I'm one of a million,

apparently.

Who is she?

She's an influencer.

Runs a travel platform

on social media or something.

Rebecca showed me her

on her socials.

Her name's uh, Sienna Hartley.

She have any belongings

on her?

- Did you find a phone?

- No.

I mean, maybe she didn't

have it on her this time?

No. This one was always one

to have her phone.

We gotta find her phone.

Well, I have Mountain

Rescue on their way.

And the coroner is gonna meet

them at the trail entrance, so.

I could just go take

another look.

Thank you, Brody.

Did you find the phone?

But I can keep looking

if you want me to.

Thanks, Brody.

Seasonal deputies

aren't here yet.

We're on our own on this one.

You're on vacation.

I can't ask you--

You don't have to ask.

Okay, well Chief, I uh,

we may not be able

to find that phone.

Just, it's probably in pieces

by that kinda fall.

And you know the terrain.

There's hundreds of crevices.

It's not an option.

We a got a tourism season

to get ready for.

The locals of this town,

they rely on that to survive.

We have to do

everything in our power

to make sure that happens.

My father understood that.

So should we.

You got it?

Yes, Chief.

Good.

I'll make some calls tomorrow.

Try and pull her phone records.

Ping it, maybe.

Do you need

to call her family?

I did.

They live in Los Angeles.

They are... pretty surprised,

to say the least.

Welcome back to Bear Lake.

We gotta find

that phone tomorrow.

- Hey.

- I heard.

Who from?

- It's all over the internet.

- Already?

Ally!

Hey, Bees.

You're back?

No, no, um, you know,

just for a little rest.

Until now.

Hey, are you okay?

Earlier today,

I ran into her, literally.

She was mad.

She said some horrible things.

- And then what happened?

- Nothing.

She walked away.

Okay.

It was just

a horrible accident.

- Can you stay for dinner?

- Uh, no. Not tonight.

You know, your brother's

had a long day, I'm sure,

and we've got an early morning.

- Yeah.

We?

Yeah, Ally's helping

with this investigation.

It's just Brody and me

for the next couple weeks so.

Anyway, we should get you

back to your cabin.

Hey, uh, Chief,

are you there?

Brody, what's up?

Yeah, we got some complaints

about some college kids

on the lake.

You know, loud music.

The usual tourist stuff.

Then take care of it.

You're on lake duty tonight.

And if you can't handle

a couple of college kids

playing loud music,

I'm putting up a "help wanted"

sign at the station.

I'll take care of it.

That kid.

He's only a few years

younger than you.

Well then,

he needs to act like it.

Come on, be nice to him.

Since when do you want me

to be nice to Brody Doyle?

I'll handle that later.

You ready?

Yeah. You know,

I'm gonna walk.

It's not that far.

And um, you should get

some rest.

- You sure?

- Yeah.

It's been a while since

I walked that route home.

I remember those walks home.

Good night.

Good night.

Bye, Bees.

We'll catch up

this week, all right?

- Coffee's on me.

- Okay. Bye!

Bye, Ally.

Not a word.

- Who is winning?

- I don't know.

Can't we just get

like another?

This is, this is my turn.

It's my turn.

Why did you throw?

It's my turn.

It's about the mindset.

Yeah!

Come on.

What is this?

You go, this is your turn.

You take this.

This is for the team.

That's my girl.

That's my girl.

Afternoon.

So, we are getting some

complaints about the noise here.

And look, I understand

it's not quite after hours yet,

but this is still

too loud, okay?

We're just having some fun.

Deputy.

I am gonna need you to turn

this music down here, okay?

And start winding all this down.

Hmm.

Are you a... a real deputy?

Or just like a police

department cadet

for the high school

or something?

No, no I'm... I'm a real,

sworn in deputy.

- Fully sworn in.

- Oh.

Oh, you're the group

from earlier.

- From the beach, huh?

- Yeah.

Yeah, and I want to talk

to your supervisor.

Austin, stop.

We're sorry.

- We didn't know. We'll stop.

- Actually, no.

No, we didn't rent

this cabin on the lake

so we could go to bed early.

Oh!

Look, the deputy here

called in backup.

Just go home, okay?

I got this.

Yeah, it doesn't

look that way.

You must be the mouth

of this group.

Dude, you're kind of

in my face.

Miles, I've told them

to dial this back, okay?

So, you can... I got this.

We paid good money.

Yeah, just 'cause you spend

the money doesn't mean

you can overrun the town.

- Okay, we're sorry.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, we're really

sorry, mountain man.

Why don't you like,

chill out a little bit?

Have a beer. Relax.

Listen to some music.

Good idea.

Look, Miles, I've... I'm...

Hey!

Man!

- Look, just stop this.

- Cut it out.

Don't make me come back here.

And tell Roy to hire

more experienced deputies

to handle these kids.

I wanna file a report

on that guy.

Yeah, I'll let

my supervisor know, okay?

Just wrap all this up.

- Of course.

- Thank you.

- Just wrap this up.

- Thank you, Deputy.

We got something here.

You are faster than you look.

- Okay, let's go for a swim.

- Austin, no.

- Let's go back inside.

- Oh, come on.

Let's swim across the lake.

There's a nice beach.

Come on!

Austin, enough. I'm not

going swimming with you like,

in the middle

of the night, okay?

Let's just go up and

hang out with everyone else.

I just wanna be with you.

Damn it, Austin!

You don't know when to quit

when you're drunk, do you?

I'm going inside

with everyone else.

What are you doing?

Um, I told you.

I'm going for a swim.

Please just come

inside with me.

We'll have a good time in there.

Last chance.

No, Austin.

I was an All-State

in high school, okay.

It was a full-run scholarship.

- I was alternate--

- Alternate for nationals.

I know.

Look, I'm not

that drunk, okay?

I'm just trying

to have some fun. I'm sorry.

I'll keep an eye out.

I can outswim anything.

Okay, just, just make it

a short swim, okay?

- Yeah.

- I'll warm you up

when you get back.

Don't worry, I'm a merman.

I'll be there

and back in 10 minutes.

- Okay.

- Time me.

- Okay.

- I'll be right back.

Just be quiet.

Hello?

Eve, is that you?

You missed me, huh?

Oh, it's gonna be

like that, huh?

Sex on the beach.

Sex on the dock.

I like it.

What are you doing here?

I didn't mean to scare you.

Roy's asleep. I got bored

and decided to go to the bakery.

They're making tomorrow

morning's donuts.

It is the best time to get them.

Fresh out of the oven.

I thought that

they were closed?

I'm the Chief

of Police's sister.

They scratch my back

and I scratch theirs.

Donuts are a cop thing,

aren't they?

Yeah, I guess they are.

- I thought you could use one.

- Well, thank you.

Did you go for a dip?

Oh, just waded a bit.

I heard some crazy party

at the lake.

Tourists?

Yeah, don't even

get me started.

Hey, are you,

are you sure you're okay?

It's just that

I haven't seen you

since I dropped you off.

And you know, your brother

was telling me that the news,

it hit you pretty hard

about Sienna.

I just feel bad.

Well, why do you feel bad?

Just had some mean thoughts

about her before.

Nothing bad. I just wanted

people to see her true colors.

See who she really was

maybe so she'd lose

some followers or something.

But not her life.

Not this.

Look, Becca, you've...

you've done nothing wrong.

Bear Lake PD.

Chief here.

I had told him not to go.

And you just went back up

to the cabin after he dove in?

I wanted to hang

with my friends.

Okay, well, you said

he was a swimmer.

- Yeah, national champion.

- Okay, so maybe he made it

to the other side

and just got tired.

It's been hours.

He said it would take him

10 minutes there and back.

I'm really worried.

Okay. Well,

my deputy's driving

to the other side right now, so.

How about I drive over, too?

Cover more ground.

Chances are he's just hunkered

down on some beach.

He might even be at a bar.

So, head in.

We'll find him.

Thank you.

Damn it.

Brody, you there?

Yeah, I'm here, Chief.

Is everything

all right over there?

No. Um, I found the...

The missing kid, I found him.

He's dead.

His body washed up

on the lakeshore.

Oh, geez, Chief.

I called the ambulance,

but I need you to come back

and finish the interview

with these kids.

Yeah. You got it.

But uh, what are you gonna do?

I'm gonna bring Ally in.

Two deaths in one day

is too much of a coincidence.

We need another set

of eyes on this.

Maybe she'll see

something we didn't.

Copy that.

Do you think it might be worth

talking to Miles, too?

Why Miles?

Well, he was at the kids'

party earlier.

He got pretty worked up.

Really got in that kid's

face about the music.

Of course he did.

Let me handle Miles.

Miles?

Chief?

Geez.

Someone's a little jumpy.

What're you doin'

hangin' out, out here?

Just comin' back

from huntin' coyotes.

Thicker than thieves

this summer.

Full compliance.

Don't worry.

Sure.

Come on in.

Take a seat.

Been a while.

Yeah.

How's the new job treatin' ya?

Hmm.

Heard about that

hiker who fell.

Yeah.

It's barely even the start

of the season

and it's off the rails already.

Looks like Ally's back.

Yeah. For a bit.

She's helping with

the investigation.

It's been a while

since us three

have been in town together

at the same time.

That gonna be a problem?

No.

It's in the past.

Hmm.

I was hoping to ask you

a couple of questions.

About the kids

across the lake?

Why'd you ask me that?

Heard the sirens.

Well, I heard

that you had a...

a run-in with them

earlier this evening.

I asked if they wouldn't mind

turning their music down.

Brody didn't really have

control over the situation.

And you felt the need

to confront them?

Well, someone had to.

He's not the most authoritative.

- No offense.

- None taken.

You know what those tourists

do to this town.

You've lived here

your entire life, Roy.

Your whole family has.

Doesn't it bother you?

Hell, I'm just trying

to do my job best I can.

Yeah, well, when I was away

serving my country,

all I thought about was being

back on the porch of this cabin.

On this lake.

There's a peacefulness to it.

Then they started

coming in droves.

You know me, Miles.

I appreciate your service.

The whole town does.

That college kid,

the one you had an issue with,

he went for a swim.

His dead body washed up

on the shore.

Did you see anything?

I was up on the ridge hunting

most of the night.

You don't think I...

No.

Thank you for your time.

Hey, Roy.

Say hi to Ally for me.

If you see her.

I will.

Aw, f*ck.

You all right?

I don't know if

I'm seeing ghosts or not.

Caden?

I know him.

He knows me.

Chief said that

they found a jumpsuit.

No body.

What're you thinkin'?

I don't know.

I just know I don't wanna

close my eyes yet.

What is it?

Well, we found

another dead body.

What?

It was around the bend.

Washed up on shore.

It was a college kid.

He went swimming

after a day of drinking.

- Drowned?

- Looks like it.

Two in one day.

It's been a long one.

Hey, Chief,

it's Brody here.

The hits just keep on comin'.

Yeah, Brody, what's up?

The coroner called in

about the swimmer.

Already?

Yeah, he says

he was electrocuted.

Electrocuted?

Well, the coroner says

it was pretty clear cut.

Deep burn marks on the palms

of the hands

and electrocution would explain

the early rigor mortis.

But how could that have

happened at a lake?

There wasn't any lighting,

or anything like that.

There could have been

an electrical wire on the dock.

The lights

on the dock were out.

According to your dad, this

happened a couple years ago.

Yeah, that's right.

Yeah, there was, you know,

the tourists,

but it was around

the same age group,

about too, as well, I think.

What?

Do you remember another

fatality that year?

- It was a climber, right?

- Yeah.

Yeah, it was, but that was

a rope break incident,

or something like that, I think.

Your dad noted that

the rope was brand new.

They just bought it

at the climbing store.

And guess where

they were climbing?

The point.

You man the station.

We're gonna go check out

that dock again.

Um, keep your radio on.

Yeah, always.

Of course.

When'd you have time

to pick these up?

No, that was just,

it was Rebecca.

For you?

Yeah, and you.

Mostly you.

We'll talk about that later.

Roy? Where are you?

Look, I was on a night hike

and I found Sienna's phone

in the rocks.

I don't wanna do anything

until you're here.

Just call me.

I'll try the station

and maybe I'll talk to Brody.

Wires are all messed up.

It looks like the wiring

has been tampered with.

Shore power box

has been rigged.

Show me.

See this cable?

Dumped in the water

next to the metal ladder.

So, when Austin grabbed

the ladder...

Fried him.

Tripped the breaker up

in the cabin.

Poor kid.

Ally, someone's making

damn sure

that tourists

don't leave Bear Lake alive.

This way.

Come on, come on.

This is Miles' property.

Roy...

That look familiar to you?

This is private property.

Miles!

This is Ally and Roy.

Lower the weapon!

I thought you were tourists.

What are you two doing here?

Somebody took

a couple shots at us

down at the dock

where we found that kid.

- I didn't hear any shots.

- Arrows.

Same as in your shed.

Wanna lower that weapon, Roy?

Not until

you explain yourself.

Roy.

Haven't shot

that bow in years.

Put down the r*fle.

- Roy.

- Put it down!

Okay, you got 30 seconds

to explain

why we tracked a sh**ter

to your property,

only to find the arrows

that damn near k*lled Ally.

Okay.

Come with me.

I'll show you something.

I have trail cams

set up on my property.

The reason I came out

the way I did

is because one of them

detected movement.

They're motion based.

Why do you have trail cams?

Hunting.

And tourists.

I caught a couple

of 'em on my property.

I have gotten a few calls

about you over the years.

Yeah well, private property

is private property, Roy.

Here, look.

What the hell's goin' on?

We got a k*ller

on the loose in Bear Lake.

- That's what's goin' on.

- Roy, Rebecca.

Brody, do you copy?

Brody, you there?

Uh, yep, yep. Copy Chief.

Sorry, I was in the bathroom.

Yeah, listen,

we've got a suspect

on the loose in Bear Lake.

He took a shot at us.

I need you to get to my house

and take care of my sister.

Yeah, of course.

Of course. Are you okay?

Yeah, we're good.

Just go to my house.

Take care of Rebecca.

I'd appreciate it.

You got it, Chief.

You got it.

Uh, B-Becca?

Yeah, it's me.

It's Brody.

- What are you doing here?

- Hey.

What time is it?

Um, something's,

something's happened,

and um, Roy just wanted me

to stay with you

for a little while, okay?

- Is he okay?

I've been trying

to call him all night.

Yeah, he's, he's okay.

And Ally's fine too.

It's just, it's all just

a precaution, okay?

Do you want any coffee

or anything?

Oh, no.

No, I'm okay.

- Sun's coming up.

- Is there anyone else?

Anyone else that stands out?

No.

Well, if there's one thing

I learned

during the Caden investigation,

it's that sleep is underrated.

We all need it.

- Take me home?

- Yeah.

Hey, maybe you should stay

with Rebecca and me.

Yeah, just let me go home,

take a shower and grab my stuff.

Yeah. I forgot I left Rebecca

and Brody together.

Probably fallen

in love overnight.

Huh.

Is it okay if I go check on her

while you get

your things together?

Yeah.

No hard feelings.

None.

Would've thought the same thing.

- Call me if you need anything.

- Bye, Miles.

Hey.

We're good, right?

Yeah, we're good.

You good?

Yeah, I'll be fine.

I'll be back in 20.

Don't move.

What do you want, Caden?

Well, we still have...

one more lesson to finish.

Who did you k*ll

for that outfit?

I didn't k*ll anyone else

in this stupid mountain town.

I'm only here for you.

Who's that?

Get over there.

Come on!

Turn around! Come on!

Come on. Move!

Caden, stop, or I'll sh**t!

How did you know?

The shades.

You always hated

having them closed.

It wasn't him.

What do you mean?

He has no clue what's

going on in this town.

If not him...

They're still not back?

No.

I suppose I can show you

this then.

I was out on a night hike

and I found this by where...

...where Sienna died.

It's Sienna's phone.

I called Roy.

His phone must be on silent.

He does that all the time.

I started to look at her videos.

I didn't wanna open anything

without him,

but I suppose

I've got you here.

How did you open the passcode?

How'd you know it?

Her birthday.

- Oh, yeah.

- Oh, my God.

- What are you looking at?

- Her last video.

- Should we watch it?

- Oh, hey, hey, hey, Becca,

I think we should really wait

for your brother

with this one, okay?

He's always telling you

to take charge of things.

Rebecca, we should

really wait, okay?

- Oops.

- We should...

You can blame me.

All right,

that was a legit hike.

A couple hours,

but it was worth it.

Check this out.

As you can see, your girl lives

for livin' on the edge.

Oh, looks like

all the mountain air

has sucked up my battery

for this hike.

I will hit you up tonight

for the nightlife of Bear Lake.

If there is any.

See ya soon!

I really wish

you hadn't done that.

Rebecca! Brody!

Rebecca, are you here?

Rebecca!

Rebecca!

Rebecca!

God! Ally!

What?

My phone's been on silent.

She's been calling me all day.

She left a message.

Roy, where are you?

I was on night hike and I found

Sienna's phone in the rocks.

I don't wanna do anything

until you're here.

Just call me.

I'll try the station

and maybe I'll talk to Brody.

Brody, do you copy?

- Brody, answer your damn radio.

- Ping the phone.

Hello, this is Chief

Roy Martin of the Bear Lake

Police Department.

Yes.

Yes, I need you to ping

that phone again.

Yeah. Send it to my phone.

Thank you.

They say it'll take a second.

That's Rebecca's phone.

I've known him my whole life.

It can't be him.

That's what they said

about Caden Hodge.

Last year,

he was on a hunting trip

before the summer

season started.

There were no tourist

deaths that year.

Year before that

was the first year

he was sworn into the force.

Electrocution accident.

Another fall from the point.

Most K*llers have patterns,

whether they realize it or not.

He's making it look

like an accident.

Miles, how quickly can you

get to the point?

Stop!

Stop!

- You don't need to do this!

- Everything was fine.

Everything until

you had to go, huh?

- I'll scream!

- Look where you are.

What's it gonna do? Huh?

What's it gonna do?

I left a message

for Roy, Brody!

- He knows I have the phone!

- I did this for you.

- Huh? I don't understand.

- Sienna.

How she treated you

when you said

she treated you like nothing.

I know how you felt.

That's how I felt

my entire life!

I didn't ask you

to do this! Ah!

You know what feels

even better than having

the power over somebody?

That's when you finally

decide to take it back.

When you've never had it

in your whole life.

What happened to you?

Them. That's what.

My father, my brother,

your father, your brother.

And all these little

college kids.

All these spoiled little kids

that come here

and spend mommy

and daddy's money

thinking they can treat anybody

they way they want to.

Like how they treated you.

How they treated me.

- What did my dad do to you?

- He was gonna fire me, okay?

I had to do it, okay?

They ran off the road.

What did you want me to do?

Help!

I'm sorry, okay?

Please forgive me.

It's the only, it's the

only way I can away with this.

Stop!

- No!

- Brody!

- It's over.

- Get away.

- Let her go.

- Get away!

Brody, don't.

Where you are,

drop 'em or I'll take us

both over, I swear! I mean it!

Roy...

- Rebecca!

- Ah!

It's over, Brody.

Hey, it's okay.

It's over.

Rebecca, I'm sorry.

No!

- Hey, hey, come here.

- He k*lled all of them.

Ally, come on in.

What's this?

It's a goodbye.

You sure about this?

Yeah.

You know, you were right.

There's uh...

There's more to life.

You know, you could

have emailed me this.

Yeah, well, maybe I wanted to

show my Captain that I'm okay.

...I've climbed trees

I'm not scared of fights,

you see

And in the clouds

I surf the breeze

I'm better

and there they'll see

Breathe in

Breathe out

Wide awake now

Every morning

I see clearer skies

Welcome them in

Oh, they're right on time